Carnegie Mellon vs Boston College: Which School is Right for You?

By Eric Eng

By Eric Eng

phd degree holders posing in school

Carnegie Mellon vs Boston College: Which School is Right for You?

Choosing the right college can be a daunting task, especially when selecting between top institutions like Carnegie Mellon University and Boston College. Both of these schools have their own unique qualities and offerings that make them attractive to prospective students. In this article, we will take a comprehensive look at Carnegie Mellon vs Boston College so you can make an informed decision in choosing the right school.

Location and Campus

The location of both universities is a critical factor to consider when choosing between them. Carnegie Mellon, located in Pittsburgh, is situated in a bustling urban environment, while Boston College, situated in Chestnut Hill, is a suburban campus.

Carnegie Mellon has a beautiful and diverse campus with modern buildings and state-of-the-art facilities. The campus is large and spans over 140 acres, with various green spaces and parks, including Schenley Park next door.

Boston College, on the other hand, is a traditional New England college campus with picturesque buildings and abundant greenery.

Entrance sign of Boston College

Another important aspect to consider when comparing the two universities is the surrounding community. Pittsburgh, where Carnegie Mellon is located, is a vibrant city with a rich cultural scene and numerous job opportunities in the tech industry.

Chestnut Hill, where Boston College is situated, is a quiet, affluent suburb with easy access to downtown Boston. Both locations offer unique advantages, and it ultimately depends on the individual’s preferences and priorities.

Admissions Statistics and Requirements at Carnegie Mellon vs Boston College

When it comes to admissions criteria, Carnegie Mellon is one of the most selective universities in the country, with an acceptance rate of just under 17 percent in 2021. Boston College, on the other hand, has a slightly higher acceptance rate of around 25 percent.

Both universities have rigorous admissions criteria, including high SAT/ACT scores, a strong academic background and extracurricular activities, and compelling personal essays.

However, Carnegie Mellon places a higher emphasis on technical and quantitative skills, whereas Boston College puts more emphasis on holistic evaluations that take into account a student’s character and values.

It’s worth noting that both universities also consider demonstrated interest in their admissions decisions. This means that students who have visited the campus attended information sessions, or communicated with admissions representatives may have an advantage in the application process.

Additionally, both universities offer early decision and early action options for applicants. These programs can be advantageous for students who are committed to attending a particular school and want to increase their chances of acceptance.

Academic Programs Offered at Carnegie Mellon vs Boston College

Carnegie Mellon is best known for its strong computer science, engineering, and business programs, with highly ranked undergraduate and graduate programs in these fields. It also offers strong programs in the arts, including drama and music, as well as exceptional programs in public policy, social sciences, and humanities.

A woman and a man practising on stage.

Boston College, on the other hand, is well-regarded for its liberal arts education, with strong offerings in the humanities, social sciences, and natural sciences.

It also has highly ranked undergraduate business and nursing programs, as well as law school and graduate programs in a variety of fields.

In addition to its strong programs in computer science, engineering, and business, Carnegie Mellon also offers exceptional programs in the field of robotics. The university is home to the Robotics Institute, which is the world’s largest robotics research and education center.

Students in this program have the opportunity to work on cutting-edge research projects and gain hands-on experience in the field.

Meanwhile, Boston College has a strong commitment to service and social justice. The university offers a variety of programs and initiatives that allow students to engage with their local community and make a positive impact.

For example, the PULSE program provides students with the opportunity to work with non-profit organizations and community partners, while the Appalachia Volunteers program allows students to spend their spring break volunteering in rural communities in the Appalachian region.

Student Life and Activities

Both universities offer exceptional campus life experiences, with a wide range of clubs, organizations, and student activities. Carnegie Mellon has a vibrant and diverse campus culture, with various student organizations, social events, and community engagement opportunities.

Boston College, on the other hand, is known for its strong Catholic identity, which is reflected in its student activities, including spiritual and religious organizations.

Additionally, both universities have a strong focus on athletics and offer a variety of sports teams for students to participate in. Carnegie Mellon has a competitive Division III athletics program, with teams in sports such as soccer, basketball, and tennis.

Boston College, on the other hand, is a Division I school and is known for its successful football and hockey programs. Both universities also have state-of-the-art athletic facilities, including gyms, swimming pools, and outdoor fields.

Faculty and Class Sizes

Carnegie Mellon has a strong and diverse faculty, with numerous experts in their respective fields. The average class size is relatively small, with a student-to-faculty ratio of around 6:1. Boston College also boasts a distinguished faculty with an average class size of around 23 students.

Both universities place a high emphasis on student-faculty interaction, with student-centered pedagogy and a focus on mentorship and research opportunities.

At Carnegie Mellon, the faculty is known for their cutting-edge research and innovation in their fields. Many professors are actively involved in research projects and often involve students in their work. This provides students with hands-on experience and the opportunity to contribute to groundbreaking research.

On the other hand, Boston College’s faculty is known for its dedication to teaching and providing a well-rounded education to its students. Professors often incorporate real-world examples and experiences into their lectures, making the material more engaging and applicable to students’ lives.

Research Opportunities and Facilities at Carnegie Mellon vs Boston College

One of the biggest advantages of attending Carnegie Mellon is the exceptional research opportunities and facilities available to students. CMU is a leader in research, particularly in the fields of robotics, artificial intelligence, and data science. It has extensive research facilities, including labs, libraries, and centers for advanced research.

a man shaking hands with a robotic hand

Although Boston College doesn’t offer the same level of research opportunities as Carnegie Mellon, it still has a robust research program with a variety of research labs, centers, and institutes. It also encourages undergraduate research and collaborative projects with faculty members.

Furthermore, Boston College strongly emphasizes interdisciplinary research, with many research projects spanning multiple departments and fields of study. This allows students to gain a broader perspective and develop a more well-rounded approach to problem-solving.

Additionally, the university has partnerships with various research institutions and organizations, providing students with even more opportunities to engage in cutting-edge research.

Cost of Attendance and Financial Aid Options at Carnegie Mellon vs Boston College

Both universities are expensive, with tuition and fees for the academic year 2022-2023 totaling around $60,000 or more for both schools.

However, both universities offer substantial financial aid packages, including grants, scholarships, and student loans, which can help offset the costs of attendance.

Carnegie Mellon and Boston College are both committed to providing financial support to students with demonstrated need and have extensive financial aid resources to help them achieve their educational goals.

It is important to note that the financial aid packages offered by both universities differ in terms of eligibility criteria, application deadlines, and award amounts. Prospective students are encouraged to research and compare the financial aid options available at each institution to determine which one best suits their needs.

Career Services and Job Placement Rates for Graduates

According to recent data, both universities have strong career services and job placement rates, with a high percentage of graduates finding employment or pursuing graduate studies within six months after graduation.

Carnegie Mellon has a strong alumni network in the technology and business sectors and has a Career and Professional Development Center that provides students with counseling, workshops, and recruitment events.

Boston College also has a comprehensive Career Center that offers similar services and resources, including internship opportunities, career counseling, and job search assistance.

In addition to the Career and Professional Development Center, Carnegie Mellon also offers students the opportunity to participate in the Tartan Network, which connects students with alumni in various industries for mentorship and networking.

The university also hosts career fairs and employer information sessions throughout the year, providing students with the chance to meet with potential employers and learn about job opportunities.

Boston College’s Career Center also offers specialized resources for students interested in pursuing careers in healthcare, education, and social services. The center partners with employers in these fields to provide students with internships and job opportunities, as well as networking events and career panels featuring professionals in these industries.

Alumni Network and Success Stories

Both universities have dedicated alumni networks comprised of successful and accomplished professionals in a variety of fields. Graduates of Carnegie Mellon are known for their contributions to the technology sector, with a high number of entrepreneurs and startup founders among their ranks.

Boston College alumni have also made significant contributions in a variety of fields, including politics, academia, and business. Many alumni from both universities have also given back to their respective communities through philanthropic efforts and volunteer work.

Business people discussing documents and ideas at meeting

Carnegie Mellon alumni have established numerous scholarships and grants to support current students, while Boston College alumni have been involved in various charitable organizations and initiatives, such as fundraising for cancer research and providing aid to underprivileged communities.

The strong sense of community and giving back is a hallmark of both universities and their alumni networks.

Athletics and Sports Teams at Carnegie Mellon vs Boston College

Sports are an important part of campus life at both Carnegie Mellon and Boston College, with an impressive range of varsity and club sports teams to choose from. Carnegie Mellon has a successful athletics program, with highly-ranked teams in soccer, track and field, and swimming.

At the same time, Boston College has a strong football program, as well as successful programs in hockey and basketball.

Additionally, both universities offer a variety of intramural sports for students who want to participate in a more casual setting. These sports include flag football, ultimate frisbee, and dodgeball. Intramural sports are a great way to stay active and meet new people on campus.

Furthermore, both universities have state-of-the-art athletic facilities available to all students. These facilities include indoor and outdoor tracks, basketball courts, weight rooms, and swimming pools. Students can use these facilities to train for their respective sports or to stay in shape.

Housing Options and Campus Amenities

Both universities offer a range of housing options, including dormitories and apartment-style living options. Carnegie Mellon has modern and comfortable dorms with a variety of amenities, such as fitness centers, dining halls, and study spaces.

On the other hand, Boston College has similarly impressive dorms, with access to dining halls, academic buildings, and social spaces, including a pub and theater.

Additionally, both universities offer off-campus housing options for upperclassmen and graduate students. Carnegie Mellon has partnerships with local apartment complexes, providing students with affordable and convenient living options.

Meanwhile, Boston College has various off-campus housing options, including apartments and houses, located within walking distance of the campus.

When it comes to campus amenities, both universities have a lot to offer. Carnegie Mellon has a state-of-the-art fitness center, a performing arts center, and a student center with a variety of dining options.

Boston College has a recreation center with a pool and fitness classes, a student center with a food court and bookstore, and a campus ministry center for spiritual and religious activities.

Diversity in Student Population at Carnegie Mellon vs Boston College

Carnegie Mellon and Boston College both have diverse student populations, with students from a range of socioeconomic, ethnic, and geographic backgrounds represented on their campuses.

diverse group of students smiling while their photo is being taken on campus

Both universities prioritize diversity and inclusion and have numerous programs and initiatives aimed at promoting a welcoming and inclusive community.

At Carnegie Mellon, the Office of Diversity and Inclusion offers a variety of resources and support for underrepresented students, including mentorship programs, cultural celebrations, and workshops on topics such as microaggressions and allyship.

Boston College also has a strong commitment to diversity, with initiatives such as the Diversity and Inclusion Summit and the Diversity Peer Educator Program, which trains students to facilitate conversations and workshops on diversity and inclusion topics.

Campus Safety Measures

Both Carnegie Mellon and Boston College are located in relatively safe and secure neighborhoods with low crime rates. Both universities also have robust campus safety measures, including campus police, security patrols, and on-campus emergency response teams.

At Carnegie Mellon, the campus police force is highly trained and equipped with the latest technology to ensure the safety of students, faculty, and staff. They also offer safety escorts for students traveling on campus late at night.

In addition, the university has implemented a comprehensive emergency notification system that can quickly alert the campus community in the event of an emergency.

Similarly, Boston College has a strong commitment to campus safety. The university has a 24/7 police department patrols the campus and surrounding areas. They also offer a safety shuttle service for students who need to travel off-campus at night.

At the same time, Boston College has also implemented a mobile safety app that allows students to quickly and easily report any safety concerns they may have.

Study Abroad Programs Available at Carnegie Mellon vs Boston College

Study abroad programs are integral to the student experience at Carnegie Mellon and Boston College. Both universities offer an array of study-abroad opportunities, with programs in over 50 countries around the world.

These programs allow students to broaden their academic horizons, enhance their cultural competence, and develop global perspectives.

At Carnegie Mellon, students can choose from a variety of study abroad programs, including semester-long programs, summer programs, and short-term programs. Some of the most popular programs include studying computer science in Japan, engineering in Germany, and business in China.

Additionally, Carnegie Mellon offers language immersion programs in countries such as Spain, France, and Italy.

Boston College also offers a wide range of study abroad programs, with options for students in all majors. Some of the most popular programs include studying theology in Ireland, political science in South Africa, and art history in Italy.

Boston College also offers service-learning programs where students can engage in community service projects while studying abroad in countries such as Ecuador, Nicaragua, and the Dominican Republic.

Internship Opportunities for Students

Internship opportunities are another critical factor when choosing between Carnegie Mellon and Boston College.

Both universities offer exceptional internship opportunities, with students able to work with leading companies and organizations in a variety of fields. Carnegie Mellon has a strong presence in the technology and engineering industries, with numerous internship opportunities available.

Boston College has strong relationships with companies in finance, healthcare, and consulting, providing students with an array of internship options.

Furthermore, both universities have dedicated career centers that provide students with resources and support to secure internships.

At Carnegie Mellon, the Career and Professional Development Center offers workshops, career fairs, and one-on-one advising to help students navigate the internship search process.

Meanwhile, Boston College’s Career Center provides similar resources, including resume and cover letter reviews, mock interviews, and networking events.

It’s worth noting that internships can often lead to full-time job offers after graduation. Both Carnegie Mellon and Boston College have strong alumni networks, with graduates working at top companies worldwide. By taking advantage of internship opportunities and career center resources, students can position themselves for success in their future careers.

Campus Resources for Mental Health Support

Mental health resources are essential to the student experience, and both Carnegie Mellon and Boston College have robust programs in place to support student well-being. Both universities offer counseling services, workshops, support groups, and resources for stress management and self-care.

Additionally, both universities have implemented programs to address students’ unique mental health challenges during the COVID-19 pandemic. These programs include virtual counseling sessions, online support groups, and resources for managing anxiety and depression related to the pandemic.

Students can access these resources through the universities’ websites or by contacting their respective counseling centers.

Student Clubs and Organizations Available at Carnegie Mellon vs Boston College

Both universities have a wide range of student clubs and organizations, providing students with opportunities to explore their passions and interests outside of the classroom.

Carnegie Mellon has over 300 student organizations, including athletics, arts, culture, and community service clubs. Boston College also has diverse student clubs and organizations, including academic, cultural, and environmental clubs.

Additionally, both universities offer opportunities for students to start their own clubs and organizations, allowing them to create communities around shared interests and hobbies.

These student-run clubs often receive funding and support from the universities, providing resources for events and activities. Students can also participate in intercollegiate competitions and conferences through their clubs, further expanding their networks and experiences.

Comparison of Student-to-Faculty Ratio

Carnegie Mellon has a lower student-to-faculty ratio than Boston College, meaning that CMU students receive more individualized attention and mentorship from their professors. However, Boston College still maintains a relatively low student-to-faculty ratio, with an average of around 10:1.

It is important to note that the student-to-faculty ratio is not the only factor determining a university’s quality of education.

Other factors, such as the qualifications and experience of the faculty, the resources available to students, and the overall academic rigor of the institution, also play a significant role.

Furthermore, while a low student-to-faculty ratio can benefit students, it is not always feasible for universities to maintain such ratios. Factors such as budget constraints and limited faculty availability can make it difficult for universities to reduce their student-to-faculty ratios without compromising on other aspects of education.

Extracurricular Opportunities at Carnegie Mellon vs Boston College

Both Carnegie Mellon and Boston College offer a range of extracurricular activities and opportunities for students to get involved in the community and develop leadership skills. These opportunities include volunteer work, community service, leadership programs, and campus governance.

Additionally, both universities offer a variety of clubs and organizations for students to join, ranging from academic and professional organizations to cultural and recreational groups.

These clubs provide students with opportunities to connect with like-minded individuals, explore new interests, and develop leadership and teamwork skills outside of the classroom.

View of hands placed on top of each other.

Overall, Carnegie Mellon and Boston College are both excellent universities with unique strengths and offerings. Choosing between Carnegie Mellon vs Boston College will depend on various factors, including your academic goals, personal values, and individual interests.

AdmissionSight provides valuable guidance to students facing the decision between Carnegie Mellon vs Boston College. By considering factors such as academic programs, industry connections, and campus culture, they assist students in making an informed choice.

Furthermore, AdmissionSight offers personalized strategies, essay review, and interview preparation to enhance students’ chances of gaining admission to either university, maximizing their potential for success.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sign up now to receive insights on
how to navigate the college admissions process.