Carnegie Mellon vs Hamilton College: A Comprehensive Overview

By Eric Eng

By Eric Eng

Male student reading a book in the hallway.

Carnegie Mellon vs Hamilton College: A Comprehensive Overview

Choosing the right college is an important decision, one that requires careful consideration of various factors. Two institutions that often come up for comparison are Carnegie Mellon University and Hamilton College. While both colleges have a lot to offer, they also have distinct differences that can impact your college experience. In this article, we’ll take a comprehensive look at Carnegie Mellon vs Hamilton College and help you decide which school is right for you.

Location and Campus Features: Carnegie Mellon vs Hamilton College

Location is often a key factor when choosing a college. Carnegie Mellon is located in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, a bustling city known for its vibrant arts scene and diverse population. The campus itself is nestled between two of Pittsburgh’s most popular neighborhoods, Squirrel Hill and Shadyside. The university has a modern campus with state-of-the-art facilities, including a cutting-edge performing arts center and an impressive robotics lab.

Hamilton College, on the other hand, is located in Clinton, New York, a small village surrounded by picturesque countryside. The campus is known for its beautiful architecture and lush green spaces. The college has a strong commitment to sustainability, and its campus is powered by 100% renewable energy.

In addition to its impressive facilities, Carnegie Mellon also boasts a strong academic reputation. The university is consistently ranked among the top 25 universities in the United States and is particularly well-known for its programs in computer science, engineering, and the arts. Students at Carnegie Mellon have access to a wide range of academic resources, including research centers, libraries, and study abroad programs.

Similarly, Hamilton College is known for its rigorous academic programs and small class sizes. The college has a strong focus on interdisciplinary learning and encourages students to explore a variety of subjects. Hamilton also has a thriving arts community, with opportunities for students to participate in theater productions, music ensembles, and visual arts exhibitions.

Admission Requirements and Selectivity: Carnegie Mellon vs Hamilton College

Admissions to both Carnegie Mellon and Hamilton are highly competitive. Carnegie Mellon boasts an acceptance rate of just 14%, while Hamilton’s acceptance rate is also at 14%. Both colleges require a rigorous application process that includes standardized test scores, transcripts, essays, and letters of recommendation. Students are also encouraged to showcase their extracurricular activities, leadership skills, and community involvement.

Group of people taking a tests in a desk.



Additionally, both colleges offer early decision and regular decision application options. Early decision is a binding agreement, meaning that if a student is accepted, they must attend the college and withdraw all other applications. Regular decision allows students to apply to multiple colleges and make a decision later in the year. However, early decision applicants typically have a higher acceptance rate than regular decision applicants.

Academic Programs and Majors: Carnegie Mellon vs Hamilton College

Both schools offer a variety of academic programs and majors. Carnegie Mellon is known for its strengths in computer science, engineering, and fine arts. The university also has highly-ranked programs in business, public policy, and psychology. Hamilton, on the other hand, offers a well-rounded liberal arts education with strengths in humanities, social sciences, and natural sciences. The college also has a unique program in public policy and a strong emphasis on writing and research.

Additionally, Carnegie Mellon offers several interdisciplinary programs, such as the Bachelor of Science and Arts program, which allows students to combine their interests in science and the arts. The university also has a strong focus on entrepreneurship, with programs like the Swartz Center for Entrepreneurship providing resources and support for students interested in starting their businesses.

Hamilton College offers several unique academic opportunities, such as the opportunity to design your major through the college’s “concentration” program. The college also has a strong emphasis on international education, with over 50% of students studying abroad at some point during their time at Hamilton. Additionally, Hamilton has several research opportunities available to students, including the opportunity to work with faculty members on independent research projects.

Faculty and Student Ratio: Carnegie Mellon vs Hamilton College

Class sizes and faculty-student ratios can have a significant impact on your college experience. At Carnegie Mellon, the student-faculty ratio is 10:1, while at Hamilton, it’s slightly higher at 9:1. Both colleges pride themselves on small class sizes that allow for individual attention and meaningful interactions with faculty.

However, it’s important to note that the student-faculty ratio is not the only factor that determines the quality of education. Other factors such as the teaching style, curriculum, and resources available also play a crucial role. At Carnegie Mellon, students have access to state-of-the-art facilities and cutting-edge technology, while at Hamilton, students benefit from a strong liberal arts curriculum and a close-knit community. Ultimately, it’s important to consider all aspects of a college before making a decision.

Research Opportunities at Both Institutions

Research opportunities abound at both Carnegie Mellon and Hamilton. Carnegie Mellon is known for its cutting-edge research in artificial intelligence, robotics, and cybersecurity. The university has numerous research centers and institutes, and students are encouraged to engage in research projects throughout their undergraduate careers. Hamilton also places a strong emphasis on research, with funding available for student-driven projects in a variety of disciplines.

Group of students talking in the stairs.

Additionally, both institutions offer opportunities for students to collaborate with faculty members on research projects. At Carnegie Mellon, students can work with professors who are leaders in their fields, and at Hamilton, students can participate in the Summer Research Program, which pairs students with faculty mentors for intensive research experiences. These collaborations provide students with valuable hands-on experience and the opportunity to contribute to groundbreaking research in their respective fields.

Extracurricular Activities and Campus Life Comparison: Carnegie Mellon vs Hamilton

College is not just about academics; it’s also about extracurricular activities and campus life. Carnegie Mellon has a strong tradition of student-led organizations and clubs, ranging from performing arts groups to political organizations. The university also has a vibrant Greek life scene and a variety of athletic teams. Hamilton has a similarly active student body, with a wide range of clubs and organizations that reflect the college’s commitment to community engagement and social justice.

One of the unique aspects of Carnegie Mellon’s extracurricular activities is its focus on entrepreneurship and innovation. The university has several resources available to students who are interested in starting their businesses, including the Swartz Center for Entrepreneurship and the Innovation Scholars Program.

Hamilton, on the other hand, has a strong emphasis on sustainability and environmentalism. The college has several student-led initiatives focused on reducing waste and promoting sustainable practices on campus.

Both universities also offer a variety of events and activities outside of clubs and organizations. Carnegie Mellon hosts several cultural events throughout the year, including the International Film Festival and the Lunar Gala fashion show.

Hamilton is known for its annual Great Names lecture series, which brings in prominent speakers from a variety of fields to speak on campus. Both universities also have a variety of recreational activities available to students, including hiking and skiing in the nearby mountains.

Study Abroad Programs: Carnegie Mellon vs Hamilton College

Studying abroad can be a life-changing experience, and both Carnegie Mellon and Hamilton offer robust study-abroad programs. Carnegie Mellon has partnerships with universities around the world, and the university encourages students to take advantage of these opportunities to gain new perspectives and cultural experiences. Hamilton has its own extensive study abroad program, with options ranging from language immersion programs to semester-long internships in various countries.

Additionally, both colleges offer financial aid and scholarships to help students cover the costs of studying abroad. Carnegie Mellon has a dedicated office to assist students with the application process and finding funding opportunities. Hamilton also offers need-based financial aid and merit-based scholarships specifically for study abroad programs. With these resources available, students can pursue their dreams of studying abroad without worrying about the financial burden.

Career Services and Alumni Network: Carnegie Mellon vs Hamilton College

Both colleges have strong career services departments that provide students with the tools they need to succeed after graduation. Carnegie Mellon’s Career and Professional Development Center offers a variety of resources, including career counseling, job search strategies, and networking opportunities.

Hamilton’s Career Center similarly offers a range of services, including resume and cover letter reviews, career workshops, and a mentor network. Both colleges also have extensive alumni networks that can help graduates find job opportunities and advance in their careers.

Three students using a laptop in a table.

However, there are some differences between the two colleges’ career services and alumni networks. Carnegie Mellon’s Career and Professional Development Center has a strong focus on technology and innovation, with resources specifically tailored to students interested in fields such as computer science and engineering.

On the other hand, Hamilton’s Career Center places a greater emphasis on liberal arts and humanities, offering resources for students pursuing careers in fields such as education and the arts.

Additionally, while both colleges have active alumni networks, the nature of these networks differs. Carnegie Mellon’s alumni network is particularly strong in the tech industry, with many graduates working at major companies such as Google and Microsoft. Hamilton’s alumni network, on the other hand, has a strong presence in fields such as law and politics, with many graduates holding positions in government and public service.

Tuition Fees, Financial Aid, and Scholarships Available: Carnegie Mellon vs Hamilton College

An important consideration when choosing a college is cost. Carnegie Mellon’s tuition and fees for the 2021-2022 academic year are $59,760, with room and board adding $14,900. Hamilton’s tuition and fees are slightly lower at $58,890, with room and board adding $16,800. Both colleges offer need-based financial aid, and a limited number of merit-based scholarships are also available.

It is important to note that the financial aid and scholarship opportunities at both Carnegie Mellon and Hamilton are highly competitive. Students are encouraged to submit their applications as early as possible to increase their chances of receiving aid.

Additionally, both colleges offer work-study programs that allow students to earn money while gaining valuable work experience. These programs can help offset the cost of tuition and living expenses, and provide students with valuable skills and connections for their future careers.

Sports Teams and Athletic Facilities: Carnegie Mellon vs Hamilton College

For many students, athletics is an important part of the college experience. Carnegie Mellon is part of the Division III University Athletic Association and offers a variety of sports teams, including basketball, soccer, cross country, and swimming.

The university has impressive athletic facilities, including a state-of-the-art fitness center and a heated outdoor pool. Hamilton is also part of the Division III University Athletic Association and has a strong athletic program, with 29 varsity sports teams. The college’s athletic facilities include a recently renovated fitness center and a stadium with turf playing fields.

In addition to the impressive athletic facilities, Carnegie Mellon also offers a wide range of intramural sports and recreational activities for students who want to stay active but may not want to participate in varsity sports. These activities include yoga, dance classes, and outdoor adventure trips. Hamilton also offers a variety of recreational activities, including a rock climbing wall and a ropes course, as well as intramural sports such as ultimate frisbee and flag football.

Student Diversity on Campus: Carnegie Mellon vs Hamilton College

Both Carnegie Mellon and Hamilton are committed to creating inclusive and diverse campus communities. Carnegie Mellon has a relatively diverse student body, with 26% of students identifying as students of color and 13% as international students. Hamilton similarly has a diverse student body, with 23% of students identifying as students of color and 8% as international students.

Students walking in front of a building.

Furthermore, both universities have active student organizations and initiatives that promote diversity and inclusion on campus. Carnegie Mellon has a Multicultural Student Association, which hosts events and provides resources for students of color and international students. Hamilton has a Diversity and Inclusion Office, which offers programming and support for underrepresented students.

Despite these efforts, both universities still face challenges in creating truly inclusive communities. Students of color and international students may still experience microaggressions or feel isolated on campus. Both universities continue to work towards addressing these issues and creating a welcoming environment for all students.

Accreditation of Both Institutions

Both Carnegie Mellon and Hamilton are accredited by the Middle States Commission on Higher Education, which is a regional accrediting agency recognized by the U.S. Department of Education. Accreditation ensures that colleges meet certain standards of academic quality and that degrees earned are recognized by other universities and employers.

Additionally, both institutions have also received specialized accreditations for certain programs. Carnegie Mellon’s School of Computer Science is accredited by the Computing Accreditation Commission of ABET, while Hamilton’s Economics Department is accredited by the Association to Advance Collegiate Schools of Business (AACSB). These specialized accreditations further demonstrate the high level of academic excellence and rigor at both institutions.

Graduation Rates and Job Placement Statistics:

Carnegie Mellon vs Hamilton College

Graduating from college is an important milestone, and both Carnegie Mellon and Hamilton have strong graduation rates. Carnegie Mellon’s four-year graduation rate is 73%, and the six-year rate is 90%. Hamilton has a similar graduation rate, with 88% of students graduating within six years. Both colleges also have impressive job placement statistics, with the majority of graduates finding jobs or entering graduate school within six months of graduation.

However, it is important to note that graduation rates and job placement statistics can vary depending on the major or program of study. For example, at Carnegie Mellon, the School of Computer Science has a higher job placement rate than the College of Fine Arts. Similarly, at Hamilton, students majoring in economics have a higher job placement rate than those majoring in philosophy.

In addition, both colleges offer resources and support to help students succeed academically and professionally. Carnegie Mellon has a Career and Professional Development Center that provides career counseling, job search assistance, and networking opportunities. Hamilton has a similar Career Center, as well as a network of alumni who are available to mentor and advise current students.

Notable Alumni from Carnegie Mellon vs Hamilton College

Finally, it’s worth noting some of the impressive alumni that have come out of both Carnegie Mellon and Hamilton. Notable alumni from Carnegie Mellon include actor Ted Danson, astronaut Judith Resnik, and musician Andy Warhol. Hamilton’s alumni list includes former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, writer Jon Krakauer, and historian David McCullough.

In conclusion, both Carnegie Mellon and Hamilton offer excellent undergraduate programs with unique strengths and opportunities. While there are differences between the two colleges, both provide a top-notch education that can prepare you for a successful and fulfilling career. When making your decision, consider your priorities and interests and choose the college that best fits your needs.

Female student standing in front of a building.

It is important to note that both Carnegie Mellon and Hamilton have produced successful entrepreneurs who have made significant contributions to their respective industries. Carnegie Mellon alumni include the co-founder of LinkedIn, Reid Hoffman, and the co-founder of Duolingo, Luis von Ahn. Hamilton alumni include the co-founder of PayPal, Peter Thiel, and the co-founder of Reddit, Alexis Ohanian. These alumni serve as inspiration for current and future students to pursue their entrepreneurial dreams and make a positive impact on the world.

If you’re set on getting into a world-class college but aren’t sure how to make it happen, we can help! AdmissionSight is a leading college entrance expert with over a decade of experience helping students just like you get into the schools of their dreams.

At AdmissionSight, we focus on offering a wide range of services, all aimed at helping students perfect their applications to catch the attention of admissions officers. Contact us today to schedule a free consultation to learn more about what we offer.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sign up now to receive insights on
how to navigate the college admissions process.