Colby vs Amherst: Which College is Right for You?

By Eric Eng

By Eric Eng

Happy female student smiling at the camera.

Colby vs Amherst: Which College is Right for You?

Are you struggling to decide which college to attend? Choosing the right college can be a challenging and overwhelming experience, but it’s an essential decision that will shape your future. In this article, we’ll compare Colby vs Amherst, two of the top liberal arts colleges in the country, to help you decide which one is right for you.

Introduction: Choosing the Right College

Choosing the right college is a significant milestone in life, and it’s essential to make a sound decision. With so many great options, it can be hard to decide which college will provide you with the best opportunities to succeed academically and personally. In this article, we’ll compare Colby and Amherst College to help you determine which one will be the best fit for you.

When choosing a college, it’s important to consider factors beyond academics. For example, the location of the college can greatly impact your overall experience. Colby College is located in Waterville, Maine, a small town with a tight-knit community. On the other hand, Amherst College is located in Amherst, Massachusetts, a larger town with more urban amenities. It’s important to consider which type of environment you prefer and how it will impact your college experience.

Another important factor to consider when choosing a college is the extracurricular activities and clubs offered. Both Colby and Amherst have a wide range of clubs and organizations, but they differ in their focus. Colby College has a strong emphasis on outdoor activities, with clubs dedicated to hiking, skiing, and rock climbing. Amherst College, on the other hand, has a strong focus on the arts, with clubs dedicated to theater, music, and dance. It’s important to consider your interests and hobbies when choosing a college, as they can greatly enhance your overall experience.

Overview of Colby College

Located in Waterville, Maine, Colby College is a prestigious liberal arts college with a history spanning over 200 years. This academic institution prides itself on its commitment to intellectual exploration and critical thinking. Colby College emphasizes interdisciplinary studies and the development of essential skills such as written and oral communication, analytical reasoning, and problem-solving.

critical thinker

Colby College has a diverse student body, with students from all 50 states and over 70 countries. The college offers over 60 majors and minors, including unique programs such as Environmental Studies and Global Studies. Students have the opportunity to participate in research projects, internships, and study abroad programs, allowing them to gain real-world experience and expand their knowledge beyond the classroom. Colby College also has a strong athletic program, with 32 varsity teams competing in the New England Small College Athletic Conference (NESCAC).

Overview of Amherst College

Amherst College, located in Amherst, Massachusetts, is another distinguished liberal arts college. With a rich history dating back to 1821, Amherst College has made significant contributions to academia and intellectual inquiry. This college has an impressive academic reputation, which is well-deserved, as the institution boasts rigorous academic programs that challenge students to develop a deeper understanding of the world around them.

One of the unique aspects of Amherst College is its open curriculum, which allows students to design their own course of study. This means that students have the freedom to explore a wide range of subjects and pursue their academic interests without being confined to a set of required courses. Additionally, Amherst College has a strong commitment to diversity and inclusion, with a student body that represents a wide range of backgrounds and perspectives. This creates a vibrant and dynamic community that fosters intellectual growth and personal development.

Location and Campus Features: Colby vs. Amherst

Both Colby and Amherst College are located in stunning regions of New England and have beautiful campuses that offer a full range of facilities and amenities. Colby College’s expansive campus covers over 714 acres of land, and it includes state-of-the-art academic buildings, 50 miles of walking trails, a garden, and even a museum. Amherst College is more compact but no less impressive, with over 100 buildings spread across 1,000 acres, including playing fields, research centers, and a museum of natural history.

reasearch facility

Colby College’s location in Waterville, Maine, provides students with easy access to outdoor recreational activities such as skiing, hiking, and fishing. The campus is also just a short drive away from the coast, where students can enjoy the beautiful beaches and seafood restaurants. Amherst College, located in Amherst, Massachusetts, is surrounded by picturesque towns and villages, including Northampton and South Hadley, which offer a variety of cultural events and entertainment options.

Both colleges are committed to sustainability and have implemented various initiatives to reduce their carbon footprint. Colby College has a biomass plant that provides heating and cooling to the campus, while Amherst College has a solar array that generates a significant portion of the campus’s electricity. Additionally, both colleges have implemented recycling programs and encourage students to use alternative modes of transportation, such as biking and public transportation.

Academic Programs and Majors Offered: Colby vs. Amherst

One of the most crucial factors to consider when selecting a college is the academic programs and majors offered. Both Colby and Amherst colleges are liberal arts colleges, which means that they provide students with a well-rounded education that emphasizes humanities, social sciences, natural sciences, and the arts. Colby College offers over 50 majors and minors, ranging from traditional disciplines like English and Math to unique programs like Human Development and Global Studies. Meanwhile, Amherst College offers an extensive range of majors across all fields, including an open major that allows students to design their own program of study.

Additionally, both colleges offer opportunities for students to pursue interdisciplinary studies and engage in research projects with faculty members. Colby College has a unique program called the Colby Liberal Arts Symposium, where students present their research and creative projects to the college community. Amherst College has a Center for Community Engagement, which provides students with opportunities to engage in community-based research and service projects. These programs allow students to apply their knowledge and skills to real-world problems and make a positive impact on society.

Class Sizes and Faculty-Student Ratio: Colby vs. Amherst

Small class sizes and a low faculty-student ratio are two critical features of a liberal arts education. This is where both Colby and Amherst colleges excel, with small classes that allow for personalized instruction and student engagement. At Colby College, the average class size is 20 students and the faculty-student ratio is 10:1. Likewise, at Amherst College, the average class size is only 20 students, and the faculty-student ratio is also 7:1. This means that students receive individualized, hands-on teaching and mentoring, which can be invaluable in facilitating their intellectual and personal growth.

Moreover, small class sizes and low faculty-student ratios also foster a sense of community and collaboration among students. With fewer students in each class, students have more opportunities to interact with their peers and engage in meaningful discussions. This can lead to the formation of strong bonds and friendships that can last a lifetime.

Additionally, small class sizes and low faculty-student ratios can also lead to better academic outcomes for students. Research has shown that students who attend colleges with small class sizes and low faculty-student ratios are more likely to graduate on time, achieve higher GPAs, and have a greater likelihood of pursuing advanced degrees. This is because they receive more personalized attention and support from their professors, which can help them stay on track and achieve their academic goals.

Extracurricular Activities and Student Life: Colby vs. Amherst

College is more than just academics, and both Colby and Amherst colleges offer students plenty of opportunities for extracurricular activities and a vibrant student life. Colby College has over 100 student organizations, including environmental groups, literary societies, cultural associations, and more. Amherst College has over 170 clubs and organizations, ranging from athletic teams to academic societies, community service groups, and musical ensembles. Additionally, both colleges have a diverse array of campus events and cultural activities, allowing students to explore and engage with their interests and passions.

a group of football fans celebrating

At Colby College, students can participate in a variety of outdoor activities, such as hiking, skiing, and rock climbing. The college is located in the heart of Maine, providing students with access to beautiful natural landscapes and outdoor recreation opportunities. Amherst College, on the other hand, has a strong focus on community service and social justice. The college has several community service groups that work with local organizations to address social issues and promote positive change.

Both colleges also have a strong emphasis on the arts. Colby College has a renowned art museum on campus, featuring over 10,000 works of art from around the world. The college also has a vibrant performing arts scene, with several theater productions and musical performances throughout the year. Amherst College has a strong music program, with several student-run a cappella groups and instrumental ensembles. The college also has a theater and dance program, offering students the opportunity to participate in productions and performances.

Athletics and Sports Teams: Colby vs. Amherst

Athletics and sports are an integral part of the college experience, and both Colby and Amherst colleges offer competitive intercollegiate athletic programs. Colby College’s “Mules” teams compete in 31 sports across NCAA Division III, while Amherst College’s “Lord Jeffs” teams compete in 27 sports across the same division. Both institutions have excellent facilities and dedicated coaching staff, providing students with opportunities to cultivate their athletic skills and develop leadership qualities.

Additionally, both colleges offer a wide range of intramural sports and recreational activities for students who want to stay active but may not want to compete at the intercollegiate level. These programs provide a fun and inclusive environment for students to participate in sports and physical activities, regardless of their skill level.

Furthermore, Colby and Amherst colleges have a strong tradition of sportsmanship and fair play, with a focus on developing well-rounded student-athletes who excel both on and off the field. The colleges prioritize academic success and encourage their student-athletes to balance their athletic commitments with their academic responsibilities, ensuring that they are prepared for success in all aspects of their lives.

Admissions Process and Requirements: Colby vs. Amherst

Admissions requirements and the application process can play a significant role in determining which college is right for you. Colby College and Amherst College have similar admissions processes, with both requiring a Common Application, high school transcripts, standardized test scores, and personal essays. However, Colby College also allows prospective students to submit a Creative Portfolio, which can showcase their achievements and interests outside of academics. Admission rates at Colby College and Amherst College are highly competitive, with acceptance rates hovering at 8% and 7%, respectively.

Structuring Your Personal Statement

It is important to note that both Colby College and Amherst College have a need-blind admissions policy, meaning that a student’s financial need is not taken into consideration during the admissions process. However, both colleges are committed to meeting the full demonstrated financial need of admitted students through a combination of grants, scholarships, and work-study programs. Additionally, both colleges offer campus visits and information sessions for prospective students and their families to learn more about the admissions process and the college experience.

Tuition, Financial Aid, and Scholarships: Colby vs. Amherst

College tuition can be expensive, but Colby and Amherst colleges are committed to providing financial aid and scholarship opportunities to qualified students. Both institutions offer need-based and merit-based aid, with Colby College covering 100% of demonstrated need and Amherst College covering 100% of demonstrated need without loans. Moreover, both colleges have a robust scholarship program that rewards students for academic excellence, leadership skills, and community engagement.

It is important to note that the financial aid and scholarship opportunities at Colby and Amherst colleges are not limited to domestic students. International students are also eligible for financial aid and scholarships, although the amount of aid may vary depending on the student’s financial need and academic performance. Additionally, both colleges have dedicated financial aid offices that can assist students and their families in navigating the financial aid process and finding the best options for funding their education.

Alumni Success Stories and Career Opportunities

The success of a college can be measured by the achievements of its graduates. Colby and Amherst colleges have produced numerous distinguished alumni, including Pulitzer Prize winners, Nobel laureates, and CEOs of successful companies. Both colleges have a career services center that helps students identify and pursue their career goals, providing assistance with resume building, job searching, and networking. Additionally, both institutions have extensive alumni networks, offering opportunities for mentorship, internship, and career advancement.

One notable success story from Colby College is that of Samantha Smith, who graduated in 2012 with a degree in Environmental Studies. After completing an internship with the Environmental Defense Fund, Samantha was offered a full-time position with the organization and has since risen to the role of Senior Director of Climate and Energy. Similarly, Amherst College alumna, Elizabeth Holmes, founded the biotech company, Theranos, which was valued at $9 billion before its downfall in 2018. Despite the controversy surrounding the company, Elizabeth’s entrepreneurial spirit and innovative ideas have inspired many young women to pursue careers in STEM fields.

Campus Resources and Support Services

Another factor to consider when choosing a college is the availability of campus resources and support services. Colby and Amherst Colleges both provide comprehensive resources to help students lead healthy and fulfilling college lives. These resources include academic support, health services, mental health counseling, career services, and disability services. Both colleges also prioritize diversity, equity, and inclusion, promoting an environment that fosters respect, understanding, and collaboration among students, faculty, and staff.

Additionally, Colby and Amherst colleges offer a variety of extracurricular activities and clubs for students to get involved in. These activities range from sports teams to cultural organizations, providing students with opportunities to explore their interests and passions outside of the classroom. The colleges also host events and lectures throughout the year, bringing in guest speakers and performers to enrich the campus community.

Furthermore, both colleges have dedicated staff and resources to support students who may be experiencing financial hardship. This includes providing financial aid and scholarships, as well as offering resources and guidance on managing finances and budgeting. Colby and Amherst colleges understand that financial stress can impact a student’s academic success and overall well-being, and strive to provide support to alleviate this burden.

Pros and Cons of Attending Colby or Amherst College

Before making a final decision, it’s crucial to weigh the pros and cons of attending Colby or Amherst College. Colby College provides an exceptional liberal arts education in a beautiful and serene environment, with personalized teaching and abundant research opportunities. In contrast, Amherst College offers a wide range of academic programs, research options, and extracurricular activities in a vibrant college town. Both colleges provide generous financial aid and career services, allowing students to pursue their dreams without the burden of debt.

Student burden of tuition fees

One of the advantages of attending Colby College is its small class sizes, which allow for more personalized attention from professors and a more intimate learning environment. Additionally, Colby has a strong commitment to sustainability and environmental stewardship, with initiatives such as a biomass plant and a solar array that provide a significant portion of the campus’s energy needs.

On the other hand, Amherst College has a diverse student body and a strong emphasis on inclusivity and social justice. The college also has a unique open curriculum, which allows students to design their own course of study and explore a wide range of academic interests. Furthermore, Amherst has a strong tradition of alumni involvement and support, with a network of successful graduates who are eager to mentor and assist current students.

Conclusion: Which College is the Best Fit for You?

Choosing between Colby and Amherst Colleges can be a challenging decision, as both institutions are excellent in their own right. However, by considering factors such as location, campus features, academic programs, class sizes, extracurricular activities, athletics, admissions process, tuition, financial aid, alumni success stories, and campus resources, you can make an informed decision that reflects your personal and intellectual goals. Ultimately, the best college for you is the one that will allow you to grow intellectually, personally, and professionally, preparing you for a successful and fulfilling life.

It is important to remember that college is not just about academics and career preparation. It is also a time for personal growth and exploration. Both Colby and Amherst offer a variety of opportunities for students to engage in community service, study abroad, and participate in cultural events. These experiences can broaden your perspective and help you develop a deeper understanding of the world around you. When making your decision, be sure to consider not only the academic offerings but also the extracurricular opportunities that will allow you to pursue your passions and interests outside of the classroom.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sign up now to receive insights on
how to navigate the college admissions process.