Colby vs Colgate: A Comprehensive Analysis

By Eric Eng

By Eric Eng

a female student thinking how to colleges

Colby vs Colgate: A Comprehensive Analysis

Choosing a college is a major decision in anyone’s life. There are so many factors to consider when deciding which institution to attend. For those who are looking at liberal arts colleges, Colby and Colgate are two popular choices. In this article, we will take a comprehensive look at both Colby vs Colgate University, comparing and contrasting various aspects to give students a clear idea of what each school can offer.

Location and Campus Comparison: Colby vs Colgate

Colby and Colgate both have beautiful and picturesque campuses. Colby is located in a small town called Waterville in Maine, while Colgate is located in Hamilton, New York. Colby’s campus is spread over 714 acres of land, while Colgate’s campus covers an area of 553 acres. There is a stark difference in terms of the populations of the two towns–Waterville has a population of around 16,000, while Hamilton has around 4,200 residents.

Despite the differences in population, both campuses are self-contained and offer a wide range of amenities such as cafes, libraries, and sports facilities. Colby and Colgate also provide students with a college shuttle bus service that runs through the town and beyond. This gives students a chance to explore their surroundings and get a sense of what life in rural Maine or upstate New York is like.

Aerial view of Colgate University.

Another notable difference between the two campuses is the climate. Colby experiences cold and snowy winters, while Colgate has a milder climate with less snowfall. This can be a factor for students who prefer a certain type of weather. Additionally, Colby is situated near the coast, providing students with easy access to beaches and water activities, while Colgate is located in a more inland area.

Academic Programs and Majors: A Breakdown of Colby and Colgate

Colby and Colgate are renowned liberal arts colleges offering a wide range of academic programs and majors. Colby has over 60 majors and minors, focused mainly on the arts and sciences, while Colgate typically has around 55 majors and minors, mainly in the arts, humanities, and social sciences.

Both institutions offer students the chance for interdisciplinary study and research, with many students engaging in research work alongside their professors. Colby’s Environmental Studies program is regarded as one of the best in the country while Colgate is known for its political science and economics programs, as well as its strong writing program.

Additionally, both Colby and Colgate offer study abroad programs, allowing students to gain international experience and broaden their perspectives. Colby has partnerships with over 200 programs in more than 60 countries, while Colgate has its own study group programs in locations such as London, Paris, and Madrid. These programs offer students the opportunity to immerse themselves in different cultures, learn new languages, and gain valuable skills that will benefit them in their future careers.

Faculty and Student Ratio: Colby vs Colgate Compared

The faculty-and-student ratio can play a significant role in a student’s education. Colby has a 10:1 student-to-faculty ratio, while Colgate has a 9:1 ratio. This means that students at both institutions are guaranteed personalized attention from their professors, allowing for more meaningful interactions and better engagement in class discussions.

Both institutions also have a highly qualified faculty with a majority holding terminal degrees and a plethora of research and teaching experience. The faculty members are dedicated to helping their students succeed, often going above and beyond what is expected of them.

However, there is a slight difference in the way the two institutions approach their faculty and student ratio. Colby believes in maintaining a smaller class size, which allows for more individualized attention and a closer relationship between the students and faculty. On the other hand, Colgate believes in a balance between small class sizes and a diverse range of course offerings, which allows students to explore a wider range of subjects and interests.

Admissions Process: How to Get into Colby or Colgate

The admissions process can be daunting for any prospective student. Both Colby and Colgate are selective institutions, with acceptance rates of 8% and 12%, respectively. However, what sets these institutions apart is their commitment to promoting diversity and inclusivity, meaning they take a holistic approach to evaluating each applicant.

The admissions process for both institutions is highly competitive, with applicants expected to have excellent grades, impressive extracurricular activities, and outstanding personal essays. However, the admissions committee considers each candidate’s individual merit and recognizes the value of diversity in their student body.

In addition to academic achievements and extracurricular activities, Colby and Colgate also value community involvement and leadership skills. Applicants who have demonstrated a commitment to serving their communities and have taken on leadership roles in their schools or organizations are highly regarded by the admissions committee.

Furthermore, both institutions offer need-blind admissions, meaning that a student’s financial situation is not taken into consideration during the admissions process. This ensures that all qualified applicants, regardless of their financial background, have an equal opportunity to attend these prestigious institutions.

Financial Aid and Scholarships: A Comparison of Colby vs Colgate

Attending college can be expensive. Fortunately, both Colby and Colgate offer various forms of financial aid and scholarships to help students afford their education. Colby has a need-blind admissions policy, meaning they do not consider an applicant’s ability to pay when making admissions decisions. They also offer generous financial aid packages, with over 50% of students receiving some form of financial aid.

Similarly, Colgate also has a need-blind admissions policy and offers extensive financial aid to their students. In fact, almost 50% of Colgate students receive some form of financial support.

However, there are some differences in the types of financial aid and scholarships offered by the two schools. Colby offers a range of merit-based scholarships, including the Colby Achievement Award and the Colby College Scholarship, which are awarded based on academic achievement and potential. Colgate, on the other hand, offers a variety of need-based grants and scholarships, such as the Colgate University Grant and the Colgate Promise, which are awarded based on a student’s financial need.

Additionally, both schools offer work-study programs to help students earn money while attending college. Colby’s program allows students to work on campus or in the local community, while Colgate’s program offers both on-campus and off-campus work opportunities. These programs not only provide students with financial support but also valuable work experience that can help them in their future careers.

Student Life at Colby vs Student Life at Colgate

College life is not just about academics; it is also about experiences and creating memories. Both Colby and Colgate offer their students numerous opportunities to get involved and engage in extracurricular activities. Colby has over 100 clubs and organizations, ranging from outdoor adventure clubs to literary magazines. Similarly, Colgate has over 200 clubs and organizations such as a capella groups, photography clubs, and even an investment club.

A person looking through a camera.

Both institutions also have a vibrant social scene, hosting numerous events and activities throughout the year. Students at both schools have access to sports facilities and activities, making it easy for them to stay active and engaged in campus life.

However, there are some differences in the student life experience at Colby and Colgate. Colby is located in a small town in Maine, providing a tight-knit community feel and easy access to outdoor activities such as hiking and skiing. On the other hand, Colgate is situated in a more suburban area in upstate New York, offering a mix of rural and urban experiences. This location allows for easy access to nearby cities like Syracuse and Utica, providing students with more diverse entertainment options.

Athletics Program at Colby vs Athletics Program at Colgate

Sports are an integral part of American college culture, and both Colby and Colgate have excellent athletics programs. Colby is a member of the New England Small College Athletic Conference (NESCAC) and has 32 varsity teams. Similarly, Colgate is a member of the Patriot League and has 25 varsity teams.

Both schools prioritize their student-athletes’ well-being and boast a strong record of athletic achievements. Colby’s field hockey team, for example, has won five NESCAC championships, while Colgate’s football team has won three Patriot League championships.

Despite the similarities, there are some differences between the athletics programs at Colby and Colgate. Colby has a strong skiing program, with both alpine and Nordic teams that have consistently placed in the top 10 at national championships. On the other hand, Colgate has a highly competitive men’s ice hockey team that has made it to the NCAA tournament several times.

Both schools also offer opportunities for students to participate in club and intramural sports. Colby has a variety of club sports, including ultimate frisbee, rugby, and equestrian, while Colgate offers club sports such as water polo, fencing, and quidditch. Intramural sports at both schools range from traditional sports like basketball and soccer to more unique options like inner tube water polo and broomball.

Alumni Networks: How They Differ at Colby vs Colgate

The alumni network of an institution can play a crucial role in a student’s career growth and development. Colby and Colgate have extensive alumni networks, providing their graduates with a vast array of career opportunities and support throughout their careers.

Colby has over 23,000 alumni spread across the world. Its alumni have gone on to work in various sectors, ranging from healthcare to the arts. Colgate also has a robust alumni network comprising over 33,000 members. Their alumni have made significant contributions in various fields such as finance, journalism, and academia.

Despite the similarities in the size and scope of their alumni networks, there are some notable differences between Colby and Colgate’s alumni communities. Colby’s alumni network is known for its strong connections to the environmental and sustainability sectors, with many graduates working in organizations focused on these issues. On the other hand, Colgate’s alumni network has a reputation for being particularly strong in the finance and business sectors, with many graduates holding high-level positions in these industries.

Career Placement Services: A Comparison of What’s Offered at Colby vs Colgate

College is an investment that students make in their future careers. Therefore, career placement resources are essential in helping students navigate the job market and secure employment after graduation. Both Colby and Colgate provide extensive career placement services, including resume building, interview preparation, and career fairs.

Colby offers its students access to a Career Center that provides career coaching, counseling, and career prep resources. Similarly, Colgate has the Center for Career Services, which offers personalized career counseling, job search assistance, and graduate school preparation.

However, there are some differences between the two schools’ career placement services. Colby’s Career Center has a strong focus on connecting students with alumni networks and providing internship opportunities. On the other hand, Colgate’s Center for Career Services emphasizes career exploration and offers a variety of workshops and events to help students discover their passions and interests.

Diversity on Campus: How Do the Two Schools Compare?

Diversity and inclusivity are critical considerations for students when choosing a college. Colby and Colgate are committed to promoting diversity and inclusivity on their respective campuses. Colby’s student body consists of students from 45 states and over 70 countries, with around 33% identifying as students of color. Similarly, Colgate’s student population comprises students from 47 states and over 85 countries, with around 25% identifying as students of color.

Both institutions have also taken strides to promote a more inclusive campus environment, with diverse programming, cultural events, and discussions and activities centered around diversity and inclusion.

diversity in campus

Colby and Colgate have also implemented initiatives to support underrepresented students on campus. Colby has a Multicultural Student Center that provides resources and support for students of color, LGBTQ+ students, and first-generation college students. Colgate has a similar initiative called the ALANA Cultural Center, which provides a space for students of African, Latino/Asian, and Native American descent to connect and engage with their cultural heritage.

Furthermore, both schools have made efforts to diversify their faculty and staff. Colby has a Faculty Diversity and Inclusion Committee that works to recruit and retain diverse faculty members. Colgate has a similar initiative called the Faculty Diversity Task Force, which aims to increase the representation of underrepresented groups among faculty and staff.

Campus Safety and Security Measures: A Comprehensive Review of Both Schools

Campus safety is a significant concern for parents and students alike. Both Colby and Colgate have comprehensive security measures to ensure the safety of their students. Colby has its own campus security department that provides around-the-clock security services and patrols. Similarly, Colgate has its own campus security department, which works closely with local law enforcement agencies to ensure the safety of students.

Both institutions have also taken steps to promote a culture of safety and security on their respective campuses. They offer safety training and programs, as well as regular safety drills, to prepare students for emergency situations.

In addition to these measures, both Colby and Colgate have implemented new safety technologies to enhance campus security. Colby has installed a state-of-the-art video surveillance system that covers all major areas of the campus, including residence halls, academic buildings, and outdoor spaces. The system is monitored 24/7 by trained security personnel, who can quickly respond to any suspicious activity. Similarly, Colgate has implemented a mobile safety app that allows students to quickly and easily report any safety concerns or emergencies. The app also provides real-time updates on any safety incidents on campus, as well as safety tips and resources.

The Importance of Location in Choosing a College: Which is Better, Waterville or Hamilton?

The location of a college can have a significant impact on a student’s overall experience. Colby and Colgate are located in different states, with varying populations and lifestyles. Waterville in Maine boasts of a vibrant arts and culture scene, with a variety of music, dance, and theatre performances taking place throughout the year. Hamilton in New York has a more rural feel and is known for its beautiful natural surroundings and outdoor activities.

Students cleaning up the beach, volunteers collecting the waste on the coast line

Ultimately, the decision of which location is better comes down to personal preferences and priorities.

However, it’s important to consider the practical aspects of location as well. For example, if you’re someone who wants to explore nearby cities and have access to a variety of internships and job opportunities, Waterville may not be the best choice. On the other hand, if you’re looking for a more secluded and peaceful environment to focus on your studies, Hamilton might be the better option. It’s important to weigh both the pros and cons of each location before making a decision.

Community Engagement Opportunities for Students at Both Schools

Community engagement is an essential aspect of a liberal arts education. Colby and Colgate both prioritize community engagement and offer students numerous opportunities to get involved. Colby has a Public Humanities program that engages in community-based research projects, while Colgate has its Upstate Institute that provides funding and support for students working on community projects.

Both institutions also encourage their students to get involved in community service activities and volunteer work. These experiences allow students to develop leadership skills, empathy, and a sense of civic responsibility.

Moreover, both Colby and Colgate have established partnerships with local organizations and businesses to provide students with internship opportunities. These internships allow students to gain practical experience in their field of study while also contributing to the community. For instance, Colby has partnered with the Maine Children’s Home for Little Wanderers to offer internships in social work, while Colgate has partnered with the Hamilton Initiative to provide internships in business and entrepreneurship.

Additionally, both schools have student-led organizations that focus on community engagement. Colby has the Colby Volunteer Center, which organizes service projects and connects students with local non-profit organizations. Colgate has the Center for Outreach, Volunteerism, and Education (COVE), which offers a variety of service opportunities and promotes social justice and community development.

Extracurricular Activities: A Look at Clubs, Organizations, and Events on Campus

Extracurricular activities are an essential part of the college experience and can be instrumental in making new friends and developing skills. Colby and Colgate offer a wide range of clubs and organizations for students to get involved in, ranging from academic clubs to sports teams to student-run newspapers and radio stations.

academic social life of students

Both institutions also host a range of events throughout the year, such as guest speakers, concerts, and cultural festivals. These events provide a chance for students to unwind and connect with their peers while also broadening their horizons.

One unique aspect of extracurricular activities at Colby and Colgate is the emphasis on community service. Both schools have a variety of service-oriented clubs and organizations, such as Habitat for Humanity and Big Brothers Big Sisters, that allow students to give back to the local community. In addition, many events on campus are centered around service, such as food drives and charity fundraisers. By participating in these activities, students not only develop important leadership and teamwork skills but also make a positive impact on the world around them.


Ultimately, choosing between Colby and Colgate comes down to personal preferences, priorities, and goals. Both institutions offer a high-quality liberal arts education, excellent faculty and student ratios, comprehensive financial aid programs, and a plethora of extracurricular activities and opportunities for growth. Students looking for a close-knit community, a strong focus on the environment, and a liberal arts education may prefer Colby, while those looking for a mix of rural beauty, academic excellence, and a focus on the community may prefer Colgate.

It is important to note that both Colby and Colgate have unique features that set them apart from other liberal arts colleges. For example, Colby has a strong commitment to sustainability and environmental stewardship, with a LEED Platinum-certified campus and a focus on sustainability in its curriculum. On the other hand, Colgate has a strong emphasis on community service and engagement, with numerous opportunities for students to get involved in local and global service projects.

Furthermore, both institutions have a strong alumni network and a reputation for producing successful graduates. Colby alumni include Pulitzer Prize winners, CEOs, and prominent politicians, while Colgate alumni include Nobel laureates, Rhodes Scholars, and successful business leaders. Ultimately, students should consider all of these factors and more when making their decision between these two outstanding institutions.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sign up now to receive insights on
how to navigate the college admissions process.