Colby vs Smith: A Comprehensive Analysis

By Eric Eng

By Eric Eng

A male Asian student weighing the factors to consider in choosing a college

Colby vs Smith: A Comprehensive Analysis

If you’re weighing your options between Colby College and Smith College, you’re likely looking for a school that will offer you the best education, college experience, and future prospects. In this article, we’ll dive deep into every aspect of Colby vs Smith, from campus facilities and student life to academic programs and faculty profiles, so you can make an informed decision about which college is the best fit for you.

Introduction to Colby vs Smith Colleges

Colby and Smith are both private liberal arts colleges located in New England. Colby was founded in 1813 in Waterville, Maine, and has an undergraduate enrollment of around 2,299 students. Smith, on the other hand, was founded in 1871 in Northampton, Massachusetts, and has an undergraduate enrollment of around 2,500 students. Both colleges are highly selective and offer students a rigorous academic curriculum as well as a strong emphasis on extracurricular activities and community engagement.

One unique aspect of Colby College is its location in central Maine, which provides students with access to a wide range of outdoor activities, including hiking, skiing, and kayaking. The college also has a strong commitment to sustainability, with a goal of achieving carbon neutrality by 2025. Smith College, on the other hand, is known for its strong programs in the arts and humanities and has produced a number of notable alumnae, including Gloria Steinem and Sylvia Plath. The college also has a vibrant campus community, with over 100 student-run organizations and a strong tradition of activism and social justice.

Colby vs Smith: Campus Layout and Facilities

Colby College’s 714-acre campus is located on a hill overlooking downtown Waterville and includes multiple academic buildings, residence halls, and athletic facilities. The campus also houses the Colby College Museum of Art, which has an extensive collection of American art and features rotating exhibitions throughout the year. On the other hand, Smith College has a 147-acre campus that’s shared with the city of Northampton. The campus includes a mix of historic buildings and modern facilities, such as the cutting-edge science center and the state-of-the-art Indoor Track and Tennis Facility. Smith also has its own botanical garden, which showcases a wide variety of plant life from around the world.

A swimming pool in a university

Aside from the academic and athletic facilities, Colby College’s campus also boasts several outdoor recreational areas. The campus has over 20 miles of hiking and biking trails, as well as a lake for swimming, kayaking, and fishing. Additionally, the college has its own organic farm, which provides fresh produce for the dining halls and local community.

Similarly, Smith College has several unique features on its campus. The college has its own observatory, which houses a 15-inch refracting telescope and is open to the public for stargazing events. Smith also has a sustainable living center, which serves as a hub for environmental education and activism on campus. The center features a green roof, solar panels, and a rainwater harvesting system.

Student Life: Clubs and Extracurricular Activities

Colby College has over 100 student-run clubs and organizations, ranging from the College Democrats to the Ski and Snowboard Club. The college also offers a wide range of varsity and club sports, including ice hockey, skiing, and lacrosse. Smith College has over 150 student-run clubs and organizations, including the International Students Organization, the Queer Student Union, and the Model United Nations. The college also has a strong emphasis on the arts, with opportunities for students to get involved in theater productions, dance ensembles, and musical groups.

Additionally, both Colby College and Smith College offer a variety of community service opportunities for students to get involved in. Colby College has partnerships with local organizations such as the Waterville Humane Society and the Mid-Maine Homeless Shelter, while Smith College has a community service office that connects students with volunteer opportunities in the surrounding area. These opportunities allow students to give back to the community and gain valuable experience outside of the classroom.

Social Scene: Nightlife and Parties

Both Colby and Smith colleges have a strong social scene, with plenty of opportunities for students to attend parties, concerts, and other social events. Colby’s nightlife mainly centers around downtown Waterville, which has multiple bars and restaurants within walking distance of campus. Smith’s party scene is centered around the student-run houses, which offer a range of themed parties and events throughout the year.

Night life parties

Additionally, both colleges also host a variety of cultural events and performances throughout the year. Colby’s Museum of Art regularly features exhibitions and lectures, while Smith’s theater department puts on several productions each semester. Both colleges also have active music scenes, with student-run a cappella groups and bands performing on campus and in the surrounding areas.

Colby vs Smith: Academic Programs Offered

Colby College offers over 50 majors and minors across a wide range of academic fields, including economics, environmental studies, and neuroscience. The college has a strong emphasis on student research and offers multiple research opportunities throughout the year. Smith College offers over 50 areas of study, including anthropology, engineering, and philosophy. Smith has a unique curriculum called “The Study of Women and Gender,” which emphasizes the role of gender in the sciences, humanities, and social sciences.

In addition to the majors and minors offered, both Colby and Smith College provide students with the opportunity to participate in study abroad programs. Colby College has partnerships with universities in over 20 countries, allowing students to immerse themselves in different cultures while continuing their academic studies. Smith College offers study abroad programs in over 45 countries, with options for semester-long programs or shorter, intensive courses during winter and summer breaks.

Faculty Profile: Experience and Qualifications

Both Colby and Smith colleges have world-class faculty members with a wealth of experience and qualifications. Colby’s faculty includes multiple Pulitzer Prize winners, MacArthur “genius” grant recipients, and Fulbright scholars. Smith’s faculty includes a Nobel laureate, a former NASA scientist, and multiple Guggenheim fellows. Both colleges have a low student-to-faculty ratio, which allows for more personalized attention in the classroom.

In addition to their impressive credentials, many faculty members at Colby and Smith colleges are actively engaged in research and scholarship. This means that students have the opportunity to work alongside their professors on cutting-edge projects and gain valuable hands-on experience. Furthermore, both colleges prioritize teaching excellence and provide ongoing professional development opportunities for their faculty to ensure that they are equipped with the latest pedagogical techniques and technologies.

Colby vs Smith: Class Size and Teaching Methodology

Colby College has an average class size of around 15 students, while Smith College has an average class size of around 12 students. Both colleges favor a discussion-based teaching methodology, which emphasizes critical thinking and active student participation. Professors at both colleges also make themselves available to students outside of class for office hours and one-on-one meetings.

students listening and talking to male teacher

Despite the similarities in class size and teaching methodology, there are some differences between Colby and Smith. For example, Colby College offers more opportunities for research and independent study, which allows students to pursue their academic interests in greater depth. On the other hand, Smith College has a stronger emphasis on interdisciplinary studies, with many courses and programs that combine multiple fields of study.

Another factor to consider is the location of the colleges. Colby College is located in Waterville, Maine, which is a small town with a tight-knit community. Smith College, on the other hand, is located in Northampton, Massachusetts, which is a larger city with more cultural and social opportunities. This can impact the overall college experience and the types of extracurricular activities available to students.

Colby vs Smith: Research Opportunities for Students

Colby College offers multiple research opportunities for students, including the Colby Liberal Arts Symposium and the Colby Undergraduate Research Experience. Smith College has a strong emphasis on undergraduate research and offers multiple opportunities for students to participate in research projects alongside faculty members, including the Smith Research Fellowship and the NSF-REU program.

Additionally, many universities offer summer research programs for undergraduate students. These programs provide students with the opportunity to work on research projects full-time during the summer months, often with a stipend or housing provided. Some examples of these programs include the Research Experience for Undergraduates (REU) program funded by the National Science Foundation, and the Amgen Scholars Program.

Furthermore, students can also seek out research opportunities through independent study courses or by reaching out to faculty members in their field of interest. Many professors are open to working with undergraduate students on research projects and can provide valuable mentorship and guidance throughout the process.

Career Services: Internships and Job Placements

Both Colby and Smith Colleges offer career services to help students prepare for life after graduation. Colby’s DavisConnects program helps students find internships and job opportunities across the globe, with a focus on experiential learning and career readiness. Smith’s Lazarus Center for Career Development provides students with resources such as resume writing workshops, interview coaching, and job search assistance. Smith also has a strong alumnae network, which can provide valuable connections and opportunities for current students.

Job opportunities for graduate students

In addition to the resources provided by Colby and Smith, both colleges also have partnerships with local businesses and organizations to offer students even more opportunities for internships and job placements. These partnerships allow students to gain hands-on experience in their field of interest and make valuable connections in their community.

Furthermore, both colleges have career fairs and networking events throughout the year, where students can meet with potential employers and learn about different career paths. These events provide a great opportunity for students to practice their networking skills and explore different industries.

Athletics: Sports Teams and Facilities

Colby College has a strong NCAA Division III athletic program, with varsity teams in sports such as football, soccer, and cross-country skiing. The college also has state-of-the-art athletic facilities, including the Harold Alfond Athletic Center and the Colby Baseball Stadium. Smith College has a competitive NCAA Division III athletic program, with varsity teams in sports such as basketball, swimming, and tennis. Smith’s athletic facilities include the state-of-the-art Indoor Track and Tennis Facility and the historic Smith College gymnasium.

In addition to varsity sports, both Colby and Smith offer a variety of club and intramural sports for students to participate in. Colby has a popular Ultimate Frisbee club and a thriving intramural basketball league. Smith offers club sports such as rugby and equestrian, as well as intramural sports like dodgeball and volleyball.

Both colleges also prioritize the health and wellness of their students, offering fitness classes and wellness programs. Colby’s Alfond Center has a fitness center, indoor track, and pool, as well as classes in yoga and Pilates. Smith’s Indoor Track and Tennis Facility offers fitness classes and personal training, as well as a sauna and whirlpool for post-workout relaxation.

Colby vs Smith: Alumni Network and Support for Graduates

Both Colby and Smith colleges have a strong alumni network and offer support for graduates as they transition into their post-collegiate careers. Colby’s Center for Career Development offers guidance and resources for alumni, while the college’s alumni network includes over 30,000 active members in fields such as law, business, and academia. Smith’s Alumnae Association boasts over 50,000 members worldwide and offers resources such as career networking events, regional alumnae clubs, and volunteer opportunities.

Additionally, both colleges have mentorship programs that connect current students with alumni in their desired fields. These programs provide valuable networking opportunities and allow students to gain insight into their chosen career paths from experienced professionals.

graduating students

Furthermore, Colby and Smith offer continued education opportunities for alumni who wish to further their knowledge and skills. Colby’s Goldfarb Center for Public Affairs and Civic Engagement offers a variety of programs and events for alumni interested in public service, while Smith’s Executive Education program provides executive-level courses and workshops for alumnae looking to advance their careers.

Colby vs Smith: Tuition Fees and Financial Aid Options

Colby College’s tuition for the academic year is $66,600, which includes room and board. The college also offers need-based financial aid and merit scholarships to eligible students. Smith College’s tuition for the academic year is $61,568, which also includes room and board. Like Colby, Smith offers need-based financial aid and merit scholarships to eligible students.

It is important to note that both Colby and Smith Colleges have different financial aid policies and requirements. Colby College requires students to submit the CSS Profile and FAFSA to be considered for need-based financial aid, while Smith College only requires the FAFSA. Additionally, Colby College offers a no-loan policy for students with a family income below $75,000, while Smith College offers a similar policy for students with a family income below $65,000. It is recommended that students research and compare the financial aid options at both colleges before making a decision.

Admission Criteria: Selectivity and Requirements

Both Colby and Smith Colleges are highly selective and have competitive admission criteria. Colby’s acceptance rate for the class was 8%, while Smith’s acceptance rate for the class was 23%. Both colleges require a strong high school academic transcript, standardized test scores (either the SAT or ACT), and letters of recommendation.

In addition to the basic admission requirements, both Colby and Smith Colleges also consider extracurricular activities, community involvement, and leadership experience when evaluating applicants. Colby values students who have demonstrated a commitment to community service and social justice, while Smith looks for students who have shown a passion for women’s rights and gender equality.

Furthermore, both colleges offer early decision and regular decision application options. Early decision is a binding agreement, meaning that if a student is accepted, they must attend the college and withdraw all other applications. Regular decision is non-binding, allowing students to compare financial aid packages and make a final decision by May 1st.

Student Diversity: Ethnicity, Gender, and International Students

Both Colby and Smith colleges have a diverse student body, with a mix of ethnicities, genders, and international students represented. Colby’s student body is 56% white, 8% Black/African American, 10% Asian, and 8% Hispanic/Latino. Smith’s student body is 51% white, 5% Black/African American, 10% Asian, and 12% Hispanic/Latino. Both colleges have a commitment to diversity, equity, and inclusion, and offer resources and support for underrepresented students.

In addition to the ethnic and racial diversity, both Colby and Smith colleges also have a diverse gender representation. Colby has a student body that is 52% female and 48% male, while Smith has a student body that is 100% female. Both colleges have a commitment to creating a safe and inclusive environment for all students, regardless of gender identity.

Furthermore, both colleges have a significant number of international students. Colby has a student body that includes students from over 70 countries, while Smith has a student body that includes students from over 60 countries. Both colleges offer resources and support for international students, including language programs, cultural events, and international student organizations.

Colby vs Smith: Campus Safety Measures

Both Colby and Smith Colleges have a strong commitment to campus safety and have measures in place to ensure the safety of their students. Both colleges have their own campus security departments and offer resources such as emergency phones and 24-hour escort services. Both colleges also have strict policies on alcohol and drug use and have programs in place to educate students about responsible behavior.

Safety public officer in university

In addition to these measures, both colleges have implemented new safety protocols in response to the COVID-19 pandemic. This includes mandatory mask-wearing, social distancing guidelines, and increased cleaning and sanitation of campus facilities. Both colleges also offer regular COVID-19 testing for students, faculty, and staff to help prevent the spread of the virus on campus.

Furthermore, both Colby and Smith Colleges have established partnerships with local law enforcement agencies to enhance campus safety. This includes regular communication and collaboration with local police departments to address any safety concerns or incidents that may occur on or near campus.

Colby vs Smith: Reputation in the Higher Education Community

Both Colby and Smith colleges have strong reputations within the higher education community and are consistently ranked among the top liberal arts colleges in the country. U.S. News & World Report ranks Colby College at #25 and Smith College at #16 in its list of best national liberal arts colleges. Both colleges have also been recognized for their commitment to sustainability and environmental stewardship, with Colby being named the #1 “Green College” by The Princeton Review in 2021 and Smith receiving a gold rating from the Association for the Advancement of Sustainability in Higher Education.

In addition to their academic excellence and commitment to sustainability, both Colby and Smith Colleges have a strong focus on community engagement and social justice. Colby College has a Center for Civic Engagement that offers students opportunities to engage with local and global communities through service projects, internships, and research. Smith College has a longstanding commitment to diversity, equity, and inclusion, and offers a range of programs and initiatives to support underrepresented students and promote social justice.

Furthermore, both colleges have robust arts programs that offer students opportunities to explore and develop their creative talents. Colby College has a state-of-the-art museum of art that houses over 10,000 works of art and offers a range of exhibitions, programs, and events throughout the year. Smith College has a renowned arts program that includes a museum of art, a theater department, a music department, and a dance program, among other offerings.

Future Prospects: Graduation Rates, Post-Graduate Education, and Employment Opportunities

Both Colby and Smith colleges boast strong graduation rates and have a track record of success when it comes to post-graduate education and employment opportunities. Colby’s graduation rate is 84%, and 70% of graduates go on to attend graduate school or find employment within six months of graduation. Smith’s graduation rate is 83%, and 70% of graduates go on to attend graduate school or find employment within one year of graduation.

Furthermore, both colleges offer a variety of resources to help students succeed after graduation. Colby has a robust career center that provides students with career counseling, job search assistance, and networking opportunities. Smith has a similar career development office that offers workshops, resume reviews, and access to job and internship postings.

In addition, both colleges have strong alumni networks that can provide valuable connections and mentorship opportunities for recent graduates. Colby’s alumni network includes over 30,000 members, while Smith’s network includes over 40,000 members. These networks can be especially helpful for graduates who are looking to break into competitive industries or fields.

Conclusion: Which College is the Best Fit for You?

Choosing between Colby College and Smith College is no easy task. Both colleges offer a world-class education, a strong community spirit, and a wealth of opportunities for personal and academic growth. Ultimately, the best way to determine which college is the best fit for you is to visit each campus, talk to current students and faculty members, and get a sense of the campus culture and community. By doing so, you’ll be able to make an informed decision about which college will help you achieve your academic and personal goals.


College Admissions

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sign up now to receive insights on
how to navigate the college admissions process.