Colgate vs Dartmouth: A Comprehensive Overview

By Eric Eng

By Eric Eng

a sorority member standing making an okay sign with her fingers

Colgate vs Dartmouth: A Comprehensive Overview

The choice of college can be a life-changing decision, and it’s important to make the right choice. Colgate and Dartmouth are two prestigious institutions that are often compared to each other due to their similar academic programs and impressive alumni networks. However, before making a decision, it’s important to examine the differences between the two institutions and determine which one is the better choice for you. In this article, we’ll do a comprehensive comparison of Colgate vs Dartmouth and examine every aspect of their campuses, academics, admissions, student life, faculty and staff, research opportunities, alumni networks, athletics programs, cost of attendance, student diversity, and career services.

Location and Campus Comparison: Colgate vs. Dartmouth

Both Colgate and Dartmouth are located in scenic areas of the United States. Colgate University is located in Hamilton, New York, a small village in Central New York State. Its campus is known for its beautiful architecture and is situated on a hill with a panoramic view of the surrounding countryside. Dartmouth College is located in Hanover, New Hampshire, a small town on the Connecticut River. The campus is spread out among hills and valleys and is known for its mix of traditional and modern architecture. Both campuses are located in rural environments, which provide a peaceful and focused atmosphere for studying.
Dartmouth College
Despite their rural locations, both Colgate and Dartmouth offer easy access to nearby cities. Colgate is only a short drive away from Syracuse, a bustling city with a variety of cultural attractions and entertainment options. Dartmouth is located just two hours away from Boston, a major metropolitan area with world-renowned museums, theaters, and restaurants. This proximity to urban centers allows students to experience the best of both worlds: a peaceful campus environment and the excitement of city life.

Another notable difference between the two campuses is their size. Colgate has a student body of around 3,130, while Dartmouth has a larger student body of approximately 6,700. This difference in size can impact the overall campus culture and student experience. At Colgate, students may have a greater sense of community and more opportunities for individualized attention from professors. At Dartmouth, students may have access to a wider range of academic programs and extracurricular activities.

Academic Programs and Curriculum: Which College Offers Better Opportunities?

Both Colgate and Dartmouth have a reputation for providing a challenging and immersive educational experience. Colgate offers over 54 majors and minors across its six divisions, including humanities, natural sciences, social sciences, interdisciplinary studies, mathematical and computational sciences, and university studies. Dartmouth offers over 50 majors in arts and sciences, engineering, and professional fields, as well as a liberal arts curriculum that emphasizes critical thinking and cross-disciplinary studies. In terms of faculty quality, both institutions have a team of dedicated and accomplished professors who are committed to teaching and research.

However, there are some differences in the academic programs and curricula offered by these two colleges. Colgate has a strong focus on undergraduate research, with opportunities for students to work closely with faculty members on research projects. Dartmouth, on the other hand, has a unique academic calendar known as the D-Plan, which allows students to take off-campus terms and pursue internships, research, or other academic opportunities.

Additionally, Colgate has a strong emphasis on interdisciplinary studies, with programs such as the Environmental Studies and Film and Media Studies programs. Dartmouth, on the other hand, has a renowned engineering program and a strong focus on the arts, with programs such as the Hood Museum of Art and the Hopkins Center for the Arts.

Admissions Policies: How to Get into Colgate or Dartmouth

Admission to either Colgate or Dartmouth is highly competitive. Colgate has an acceptance rate of 12%, and Dartmouth has an acceptance rate of 6%. Both institutions require applicants to have excellent grades, strong extracurricular activities, stellar test scores, and outstanding recommendations. However, Colgate places greater emphasis on a student’s academic achievements, while Dartmouth looks for students who have demonstrated leadership and a commitment to the community. In terms of financial aid, both institutions provide generous financial aid packages that meet the demonstrated financial needs of their students.

Student writing college or university application.
It is important to note that both Colgate and Dartmouth have holistic admissions processes, meaning that they consider the whole applicant and not just their academic achievements or extracurricular activities. This includes factors such as personal essays, interviews, and demonstrated interest in the institution. Additionally, both schools have a need-blind admissions policy, meaning that they do not consider an applicant’s ability to pay when making admissions decisions. This ensures that all qualified students, regardless of their financial situation, have an equal opportunity to attend these prestigious institutions.

Student Life: Social Scene, Clubs, and Extracurriculars at Colgate and Dartmouth

Both Colgate and Dartmouth have a vibrant social scene and numerous extracurricular activities. Colgate has over 200 student clubs and organizations, including academic, social, athletic, cultural, and community service clubs. Dartmouth has over 350 student organizations that cover a wide range of interests, from sports to music to politics. Both institutions have a strong Greek life, with a significant percentage of students participating in fraternities and sororities. In terms of events and activities, both Colgate and Dartmouth host a wide range of cultural events, speakers, concerts, and athletic competitions that provide students with ample opportunities for socializing and networking.

Faculty and Staff: Quality of Teaching and Support at Both Institutions

Both Colgate and Dartmouth pride themselves on the quality of faculty and staff. Both institutions have rigorous hiring processes to ensure that they attract the best and brightest in their fields. Both institutions have small class sizes, with a student-to-faculty ratio of 9:1 at Colgate and 7:1 at Dartmouth. Additionally, both institutions have extensive support programs for students, such as tutoring, advising, counseling, career services, and health and wellness programs.

Furthermore, both Colgate and Dartmouth have faculty members who are actively engaged in research and scholarship, which allows them to bring the latest developments and insights into their teaching. This means that students at both institutions have the opportunity to learn from experts in their fields who are at the forefront of new discoveries and innovations.

Moreover, both institutions have a strong commitment to diversity and inclusion, and this is reflected in their faculty and staff. Both Colgate and Dartmouth have made significant efforts to recruit and retain faculty and staff from underrepresented groups and to create a welcoming and supportive environment for all students, regardless of their background or identity.

Research Opportunities: What to Expect at Colgate vs Dartmouth

Both Colgate and Dartmouth have a strong commitment to research and provide extensive opportunities for students to engage in research projects with their professors. Colgate students can conduct research in a variety of fields, including the social sciences, natural sciences, and humanities. Dartmouth students have access to research opportunities in fields such as medicine, engineering, and computer science. Both institutions have state-of-the-art research facilities and equipment that allow students to conduct cutting-edge research projects.

two male engineers working inside a factory

At Colgate, students can participate in research projects through various programs, such as the Summer Scholars Program and the Sophomore Research Seminar. These programs provide students with the opportunity to work closely with faculty members and gain hands-on experience in their field of study. Additionally, Colgate has a strong emphasis on interdisciplinary research, encouraging students to collaborate across different departments and fields.

Dartmouth also offers unique research opportunities, such as the Dartmouth Outing Club, which allows students to conduct research in outdoor and wilderness settings. The college also has a strong focus on experiential learning, providing students with opportunities to conduct research abroad and participate in internships with research organizations. Dartmouth’s Thayer School of Engineering also offers a unique program that allows students to work on real-world engineering projects for clients, providing valuable experience in project management and teamwork.

Alumni Networks: Are Colgate vs Dartmouth Graduates More Successful?

Both Colgate and Dartmouth have impressive alumni networks. Colgate has over 31,000 alumni worldwide, and Dartmouth has over 73,000 alumni worldwide. Both institutions have a strong reputation for producing successful and influential graduates who go on to make a significant impact in their fields. However, Dartmouth has a slightly more global alumni network, with graduates working in more diverse areas of the world.

Additionally, both Colgate and Dartmouth have active alumni associations that provide networking opportunities, career resources, and social events for their graduates. These associations help to strengthen the alumni community and provide ongoing support for graduates throughout their careers. Colgate’s alumni association, known as the Colgate Alumni Corporation, has over 50 regional chapters worldwide, while Dartmouth’s alumni association, known as the Dartmouth Alumni Association, has over 70 regional clubs and affinity groups. Both associations offer a variety of programs and services to help alumni stay connected and engaged with their alma mater.

Athletics Programs: Comparing Colgate vs Dartmouth’s Sports Teams

Both Colgate and Dartmouth have strong athletics programs that offer a wide range of sports for students to participate in. Colgate is a Division I school and offers varsity sports in 25 different sports, including football, basketball, and ice hockey. Dartmouth is also a Division I school and offers varsity sports in 35 different sports, including skiing, sailing, and fencing. Both institutions have state-of-the-art athletic facilities and a strong commitment to athletics as an integral part of student life. Additionally, both Colgate and Dartmouth offer extensive intramural and club sports programs that allow students to participate in sports at a more recreational level.

athletes running in the oval field

Despite the similarities in their athletics programs, there are some notable differences between Colgate and Dartmouth. For example, Colgate has a strong lacrosse program, with both the men’s and women’s teams consistently ranking among the top in the country. Dartmouth, on the other hand, has a renowned rowing program, with its men’s and women’s crews winning numerous national championships over the years.

Another difference between the two schools is their approach to athletics scholarships. While Colgate offers athletic scholarships to its varsity athletes, Dartmouth does not. Instead, Dartmouth provides need-based financial aid to all students, including athletes, and does not offer merit-based scholarships. This means that while Colgate may attract more highly recruited athletes with its scholarship offerings, Dartmouth’s approach ensures that all students have access to financial aid regardless of their athletic ability.

Cost of Attendance: Tuition, Fees, Scholarships, and Financial Aid Packages at Both Colleges

Both Colgate and Dartmouth are expensive institutions to attend, with the cost of attendance exceeding $83,814 per year. However, both institutions provide generous financial aid packages to help students with their educational costs. Colgate meets 100% of the demonstrated financial need for students, and Dartmouth also provides a comprehensive financial aid program that meets the full demonstrated financial need of its students. Additionally, both institutions provide scholarships and grants to students who demonstrate academic excellence and financial need.

It is important to note that the cost of attendance at both Colgate and Dartmouth includes not only tuition and fees, but also room and board, textbooks, and other expenses. However, both institutions offer various resources to help students manage their costs, such as work-study programs and student employment opportunities. Additionally, both colleges have financial aid offices that are available to assist students and their families with any questions or concerns regarding the financial aid process.

Student Diversity: Racial, Ethnic, and Gender Representation Comparison Between Colgate vs Dartmouth

Both Colgate and Dartmouth are committed to providing a diverse and inclusive educational environment. Colgate has a student body that is 56% female and 44% male, with 10% of students identifying as underrepresented minorities. Dartmouth has a student body that is 49% female and 51% male, with 35% of students identifying as members of underrepresented minority groups. Both institutions have ongoing initiatives aimed at increasing diversity and supporting historically underrepresented groups on campus.

Group of students walking in the campus.

It is important to note that while both Colgate and Dartmouth have made strides in promoting diversity, there is still work to be done. For example, both institutions have been criticized for their lack of socioeconomic diversity, with a significant portion of their student bodies coming from affluent backgrounds. Additionally, while the percentage of underrepresented minorities at Dartmouth is higher than at Colgate, there is still a need for greater representation and support for these groups on both campuses.

Career Services: How Each College Prepares Students for Their Future Careers

Both Colgate and Dartmouth have extensive career services programs that help prepare students for their future careers. These programs provide opportunities for students to connect with alumni, attend career fairs, participate in mock interviews, and receive guidance on job searching and career development. Both institutions have strong networks of alumni who are committed to helping students find career opportunities. Additionally, both institutions have partnerships with organizations and businesses that provide internships and job opportunities for students.

Overall, Colgate and Dartmouth are both excellent institutions that offer a rigorous and rewarding educational experience. Each institution has its own unique strengths and weaknesses that need to be considered before making a decision. By examining every aspect of both colleges, we hope that this article has provided a comprehensive comparison that will help you make an informed decision about which college is the best fit for you. Good luck in your educational journey!

One of the unique features of Colgate’s career services program is its emphasis on entrepreneurship. The university has a dedicated entrepreneurship program that provides students with resources and support to start their own businesses. This program includes mentorship from successful entrepreneurs, access to funding opportunities, and workshops on business development. Colgate’s entrepreneurship program has produced several successful startups, and many graduates have gone on to become successful entrepreneurs.

Dartmouth’s career services program, on the other hand, has a strong focus on international opportunities. The university has partnerships with organizations and businesses around the world, providing students with opportunities to work and study abroad. Dartmouth also offers language programs and cultural immersion experiences to help students develop the skills they need to succeed in a globalized world. Many Dartmouth graduates have gone on to work for international organizations or have pursued careers that require a global perspective.



Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sign up now to receive insights on
how to navigate the college admissions process.