Colgate vs Notre Dame: A Comprehensive Look at Two Elite Universities

By Eric Eng

By Eric Eng

young student boy smiling proudly and confidently making number one pose triumphantly, feeling like a leader

Colgate vs Notre Dame: A Comprehensive Look at Two Elite Universities

Choosing the right university is one of the most important decisions a student can make, as it can shape their future in many ways. The decision-making process can become particularly challenging when two top-tier universities, Colgate University and the University of Notre Dame, are in contention. This article will provide a comprehensive comparison of Colgate vs. Notre Dame in terms of their history, campus, cost, admissions, student demographics, academic programs, faculty, campus life, career prospects, resources, and alumni networks. By the end of this article, readers will have a well-rounded understanding of the similarities and differences between Colgate and Notre Dame, empowering them to make an informed decision about their higher education journey.

Introduction: Understanding the Importance of Choosing the Right University

Before diving into the specifics of each university, it’s essential to understand the importance of choosing the right university. A university is not just a place to earn a degree; it’s a community where students can learn, grow, and develop important life skills, connections, and experiences. The choice of university can impact a student’s career trajectory, social circle, mental health, and even their future family and housing decisions. Therefore, it’s crucial to choose a university that aligns with one’s needs, preferences, and goals.

A Brief History of Colgate and Notre Dame University

Colgate University was established in 1819 in Hamilton, New York, as a Baptist seminary. It gradually evolved into a liberal arts university that offers undergraduate and graduate degrees in various fields, including the arts, humanities, social sciences, and natural sciences. Colgate University is known for its rigorous academic standards, personalized attention, and commitment to diversity, community service, and interdisciplinary education.

The University of Notre Dame was founded in 1842 in Notre Dame, Indiana, by the Congregation of Holy Cross, a Catholic institution. Notre Dame is renowned for its Catholic identity, research excellence, and commitment to global engagement and social responsibility. The university offers undergraduate, graduate, and professional degrees in areas such as business, law, engineering, medicine, and the arts and humanities.

View of the University of Notre Dame

Colgate University has a long-standing tradition of promoting sustainability and environmental responsibility. The university has implemented various initiatives to reduce its carbon footprint, such as using renewable energy sources, promoting energy conservation, and reducing waste. Colgate University has also established a sustainability office that works to educate students, faculty, and staff on environmental issues and promote sustainable practices on campus.

The University of Notre Dame has a strong athletic program, with its football team being particularly well-known. The Fighting Irish football team has a storied history, having won 11 national championships and produced numerous NFL players. Notre Dame also has a strong tradition of community service, with many students participating in service projects both locally and globally through the university’s Center for Social Concerns.

Location Matters: Comparing the Campuses of Colgate and Notre Dame

Both Colgate University and the University of Notre Dame have beautiful and spacious campuses that offer various amenities and facilities. Colgate’s campus is located in the quaint village of Hamilton, New York, and has a classic New England charm. The campus features state-of-the-art academic buildings, residence halls, athletic facilities, and outdoor spaces, including its own golf course. The campus is also close to various cultural and natural attractions, such as the Munson-Williams-Proctor Arts Institute and the Adirondack Mountains.

The University of Notre Dame’s campus is situated in a picturesque setting, with the historic Notre Dame Basilica as its centerpiece. The campus spans over 1,265 acres and includes numerous academic buildings, residence halls, sports facilities, and landmarks such as the Golden Dome, the Grotto of Our Lady of Lourdes, and the Word of Life Mural. Although the campus is secluded from the city, it’s only 5 miles away from South Bend, Indiana, which offers students access to various cultural, recreational, and shopping destinations.

One notable difference between the two campuses is their climate. Colgate University experiences cold and snowy winters, with temperatures often dropping below freezing, while Notre Dame has a more moderate climate with milder winters and warmer summers. This difference in climate can impact the types of outdoor activities and events that are available on each campus throughout the year. Despite this difference, both campuses offer a wide range of indoor and outdoor activities for students to enjoy, making them both great options for those seeking a well-rounded college experience.

Cost of Attendance: Colgate vs. Notre Dame

The cost of attending a university can be a significant factor in a student’s decision-making process. According to the College Board, the average cost of attendance for the academic year at Colgate University is $83,814, including tuition, fees, room, and board. However, the university offers financial aid, scholarships, and work-study programs that can reduce the overall cost for eligible students.

On the other hand, the University of Notre Dame’s average cost of attendance for the same academic year is $80,071. The university also provides financial assistance to eligible students through grants, scholarships, and loans, as well as work-study opportunities. Therefore, in terms of overall cost, both universities are comparable, although specific financial aid packages may differ depending on the student’s background and circumstances.

View of coins and money placed next to a label of student debt.

It is important to note that the cost of attendance is not the only factor to consider when choosing a university. Students should also consider the quality of education, available resources, campus culture, and location. For example, Colgate University is located in a small town in upstate New York, while the University of Notre Dame is located in a suburban area in Indiana. These differences in location can greatly impact a student’s overall college experience.

Additionally, students should also consider the potential return on investment in their education. According to PayScale’s 2021 College ROI Report, the 20-year net ROI for Colgate University is $1,013,000, while the 20-year net ROI for the University of Notre Dame is $1,052,000. This means that graduates from both universities can expect to earn a significant return on their investment in their education, with Notre Dame having a slightly higher ROI.

Admission Rates and Criteria: Colgate vs. Notre Dame

Admission to Colgate University and the University of Notre Dame is highly selective, with both institutions receiving thousands of applications each year. According to the U.S. News & World Report, Colgate’s acceptance rate was 12%, and the university considers factors such as academic performance, extracurricular involvement, essay quality, and demonstrated interest in the institution.

The University of Notre Dame’s acceptance rate for the same year was 13%, making it one of the most competitive universities in the US. The university also considers several aspects of an applicant’s profile, such as academic achievements, standardized test scores, recommendation letters, and essays. Moreover, the university has a holistic admissions process that assesses each student’s potential to contribute to Notre Dame’s mission and community.

Despite the high selectivity of both universities, there are some differences in their admissions criteria. For instance, Colgate University places a strong emphasis on a student’s academic performance, with the average GPA of admitted students being 3.9. In contrast, the University of Notre Dame considers a student’s extracurricular involvement and leadership skills to be equally important, with the university seeking to admit students who have made a positive impact in their communities.

It is also worth noting that both universities offer need-blind admissions, meaning that an applicant’s financial situation does not affect their chances of being admitted. However, both universities have limited financial aid resources, and students are encouraged to apply for scholarships and grants to help cover the cost of attendance.

Student Demographics: Colgate vs. Notre Dame

Both Colgate and Notre Dame value diversity, equity, and inclusion as core principles and strive to maintain a welcoming and respectful campus environment for students of all backgrounds. According to the universities’ official websites, Colgate’s student body consists of approximately 3,100 undergraduate and graduate students from 47 states and 91 countries, with a student-faculty ratio of 9:1.

Intelligent international students preparing for final exams at public park, using laptop and notebooks

Notre Dame’s student body includes around 13,000 undergraduate and graduate students from all 50 states and over 100 countries worldwide. The student-faculty ratio at Notre Dame is 9:1, indicating a similar commitment to personalized education as Colgate.

Both universities have taken steps to ensure that their campuses are inclusive and welcoming to students of all backgrounds. Colgate has a Center for Learning, Teaching, and Research that offers resources and support for students from diverse backgrounds, including first-generation college students, students of color, and LGBTQ+ students. Notre Dame has a Multicultural Student Programs and Services office that provides similar resources and support for underrepresented students on campus. Both universities also offer a variety of student organizations and clubs that celebrate diversity and promote inclusivity.

Academics: Colgate vs. Notre Dame

Academic excellence is at the heart of Colgate and Notre Dame’s mission, with both universities offering a wide range of academic programs that cater to various interests and career goals.

Colgate University offers 56 majors, including arts and sciences, professional studies, interdisciplinary programs, and off-campus study options. The university also has a robust liberal arts curriculum that emphasizes critical thinking, communication skills, and interdisciplinary exploration. The university’s academic programs are delivered by faculty members who are both accomplished scholars and dedicated educators, ensuring a high-quality educational experience for students.

The University of Notre Dame offers over 75 undergraduate majors and more than 50 graduate programs in diverse fields such as business, engineering, law, medicine, humanities, and social sciences. The university is committed to providing a well-rounded education that integrates intellectual, moral, and spiritual development. Notre Dame also emphasizes the value of research, innovation, and experiential learning, enabling students to apply their knowledge and skills in practical settings.

female nurse in scrubs showing heart gesture and smiling

Both universities have unique academic programs that set them apart from each other. Colgate University offers a unique program called the Thought Into Action Entrepreneurship Institute, which provides students with the opportunity to develop their entrepreneurial skills and launch their own businesses. Notre Dame, on the other hand, offers a program called the Hesburgh Program in Public Service, which provides students with the opportunity to engage in community service and social justice work.

Additionally, both universities have strong study abroad programs that allow students to gain international experience and broaden their perspectives. Colgate University has study abroad programs in over 20 countries, including Australia, China, France, and Spain. Notre Dame has study abroad programs in over 30 countries, including Argentina, Italy, Japan, and South Africa.

Faculty and Student Ratio: Colgate vs. Notre Dame

At both Colgate and Notre Dame, the student-faculty ratio is relatively low, indicating the universities’ commitment to personalized education, mentoring, and advising.

Colgate has a student-faculty ratio of 9:1, meaning that students have ample opportunities to engage with their professors, ask questions, seek feedback, and receive individualized support. The faculty members at Colgate are renowned scholars who have excellent teaching skills and are committed to the success of their students.

The University of Notre Dame has a student-faculty ratio of 9:1, indicating a similar dedication to student-centered education. The university’s faculty members are accomplished researchers, professionals, and educators who value mentorship and collaboration. Notre Dame also offers various resources and programs that facilitate faculty-student interaction, such as office hours, research opportunities, and experiential learning projects.

However, it is important to note that student-faculty ratio is not the only factor that determines the quality of student-teacher interaction. Other factors such as class size, teaching methods, and the availability of resources also play a crucial role. For instance, a university with a higher student-faculty ratio may still offer excellent student-teacher interaction if the classes are small, and the professors are accessible and responsive to students’ needs.

Campus Life: Colgate vs. Notre Dame

Student life at Colgate and Notre Dame is dynamic, diverse, and engaging, with various clubs, organizations, activities, and events that cater to students’ interests and passions.

Colgate offers over 200 clubs and organizations that cover various areas such as arts, culture, community service, politics, recreation, sports, and social life. The university also has 25 NCAA Division I athletic teams that compete in the Patriot League, and the university’s facilities, including the field house and the Reid Athletic Center, provide ample opportunities for fitness, recreation, and sports events.

The University of Notre Dame also has a vibrant campus life, with over 400 student clubs and organizations that reflect the university’s values and identity. The university is particularly known for its Division I athletic teams, including football, basketball, and hockey. The university’s athletic facilities, including the Purcell Pavilion, the Compton Family Ice Center, and the Notre Dame Stadium, are state-of-the-art and attract thousands of fans and supporters each year.

Aside from the numerous clubs and sports teams, both Colgate and Notre Dame offer a wide range of extracurricular activities that allow students to explore their interests and develop new skills. For instance, Colgate has a robust music program that includes cappella groups, jazz ensembles, and orchestras. The university also has a theater program that produces several plays and musicals each year, providing students with opportunities to act, direct, and design sets and costumes.

Similarly, Notre Dame has a thriving arts scene, with several galleries, museums, and performance spaces on campus. The university’s Snite Museum of Art houses over 29,000 works of art from around the world, while the DeBartolo Performing Arts Center hosts concerts, plays, and dance performances throughout the year. Notre Dame also has a strong tradition of service and social justice, with several organizations dedicated to community outreach, advocacy, and activism.

Career Prospects: Employment Opportunities Post-Graduation from Colgate and Notre Dame

Both Colgate and Notre Dame provide students with excellent career preparation and networking opportunities, leading to high employment rates and competitive salaries after graduation.

According to Colgate’s 2020 first destination survey, 97% of the university’s graduates secured employment or enrolled in graduate school within six months after graduation, with an average salary of $60,270. The university’s Career Services Office provides various resources such as counseling, job postings, resume reviews, alumni networking, and career fairs that assist students in finding internships and job opportunities that align with their goals and interests.

a resume printed on paper and a pair of glasses and pen sitting on top of the paper

Notre Dame’s Career Services Office also offers comprehensive career development services that support students’ professional growth and success. According to the university’s Career Outcomes Survey, 97% of Notre Dame graduates secured employment or enrolled in graduate school within six months after graduation, with an average starting salary of $67,700. The university also provides various career-related programs, such as the Wall Street Club, the Consulting Club, and the Engineering Leadership Program, that expose students to high-demand industries and prepare them for leadership roles.

In addition to the career services offered by Colgate and Notre Dame, both universities have strong alumni networks that provide students with valuable connections and opportunities. Colgate’s alumni network spans across various industries and includes notable figures such as former Secretary of State, Hillary Clinton, and Pulitzer Prize-winning author, Jane Smiley. Notre Dame’s alumni network is also extensive and includes prominent figures such as former Vice President, Joe Biden, and CEO of IBM, Ginni Rometty.

Furthermore, both universities offer various experiential learning opportunities that allow students to gain hands-on experience in their desired fields. Colgate’s Thought Into Action Entrepreneurship Institute provides students with resources and mentorship to start their own businesses, while Notre Dame’s Center for Social Concerns offers service-learning programs that allow students to engage with local communities and address social issues.

Campus Resources: Libraries, Research Facilities, Health Services, etc.

Both Colgate and Notre Dame offer various campus resources and services that support students’ academic, personal, and professional growth and well-being.

Colgate’s Case Library and Geyer Center for Information Technology is a state-of-the-art facility that provides students with access to over 1.3 million print and digital resources, specialized collections, research assistance, and technology support. The university’s research centers, institutes, and initiatives, such as the Center for Women’s Studies, the Center for Learning, Teaching, and Research, and the Upstate Institute, foster interdisciplinary exploration and engagement with real-world issues.

The University of Notre Dame’s Hesburgh Libraries includes over 3.5 million print and electronic volumes, research databases, and multimedia collections. The university’s research facilities, centers, and institutes, such as the Notre Dame Initiative for Global Development, the Eck Institute for Global Health, and the London Global Gateway, enable students to conduct cutting-edge research and scholarship in various fields. Notre Dame also provides comprehensive health and wellness services through the University Health Center, the Counseling Center, and the RecSports program.

Additionally, both universities offer career services that help students explore career paths, develop job search strategies, and connect with potential employers. Colgate’s Center for Career Services provides individualized career counseling, workshops, networking events, and internship and job opportunities. Notre Dame’s Career Center offers similar services, as well as career fairs, employer information sessions, and alumni mentoring programs. These resources and services help students prepare for life after graduation and achieve their professional goals.

Alumni Networks: The Importance of Networking for Future Career Opportunities

The alumni networks of Colgate and Notre Dame are extensive and supportive, connecting graduates with opportunities, resources, and communities worldwide.

Colgate has over 32,000 active alumni who span the globe and represent diverse industries, professions, and organizations. The university’s Alumni Relations Office offers various events, programs, and services that facilitate alumni engagement, mentoring, and collaboration, such as the Alumni Council, the Career Services Network, and the Reunion Weekend. The university’s alumni network also provides job postings, internships, and referrals that benefit current students and recent graduates.

Internship for college students

The University of Notre Dame’s alumni network includes over 140,000 graduates from all 50 states and over 150 countries, who are leaders in various fields such as politics, business, education, non-profit work, and athletics. The university’s Alumni Association provides various resources and programs that foster alumni engagement, networking, and support, including the Alumni Board, the MentorND program, and the Notre Dame Clubs Network. The university’s alumni network also provides career-related services, such as job postings, internships, and career counseling.

Conclusion: Which University Fits Your Needs?

Choosing between Colgate and Notre Dame can be a challenging but rewarding process, as both universities offer outstanding academic programs, campus life, resources, and alumni networks. Students should consider their personal and career goals, preferences, and values when making their decision, and explore each university in-depth through visits, research, and conversations with faculty, students, and alumni.

Ultimately, the choice of university depends on the student’s unique needs and aspirations. However, regardless of the decision, students can feel confident that they will receive a transformative and rewarding education at either Colgate or the University of Notre Dame, and embark on a successful and fulfilling career and life journey.



Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sign up now to receive insights on
how to navigate the college admissions process.