Colgate vs Smith: Which University is Right for You?

By Eric Eng

By Eric Eng

sorority member isolated on purple background with thumbs up gesture and smiling

Colgate vs Smith: Which University is Right for You?

Are you trying to decide between Colgate University and Smith University? Both of these institutions are renowned for their academic excellence, but they each offer unique experiences and advantages. In this article, we will explore every aspect of Colgate vs Smith to help you determine which is the right fit for you.

Introduction: Brief Overview of Colgate vs. Smith 

Colgate University is a private liberal arts university located in Hamilton, New York. It was founded in 1819 and is considered one of the oldest universities in the United States. Smith University, on the other hand, is a private women’s liberal arts college located in Northampton, Massachusetts. It was founded in 1871 and is known for its impressive alumnae network and dedication to women’s education.

Both universities offer a wide range of academic programs and extracurricular activities for their students. Colgate University has a strong emphasis on research and offers majors in fields such as biology, computer science, and economics. Smith University, on the other hand, has a strong focus on the arts and humanities, offering majors in fields such as English, history, and studio art. Both universities have a strong commitment to providing their students with a well-rounded education and preparing them for successful careers and fulfilling lives.

Campus Life: Housing, Facilities, and Amenities

When it comes to campus life, Colgate and Smith both offer exceptional amenities. Colgate has a variety of housing options for its students, including traditional dormitories and apartment-style living. The university also has a variety of facilities, including a brand-new sports complex and a state-of-the-art performing arts center. Smith University offers a similarly impressive set of amenities, including beautiful historic buildings and modern facilities. Smith’s housing options include both traditional dormitories and apartment-style living, and the university has a variety of dining options to choose from.

Students laughing together in their apartments

Additionally, both universities offer a range of extracurricular activities and clubs for students to get involved in. Colgate has over 200 student organizations, including academic clubs, cultural groups, and sports teams. Smith also has a diverse range of clubs and organizations, including a student-run radio station and a feminist collective. Both universities also have extensive outdoor recreation programs, with opportunities for hiking, skiing, and other outdoor activities in the surrounding areas.

Location: Colgate vs Smith

One major difference between Colgate and Smith is their location. Colgate is located in a rural setting, giving students the opportunity to explore the natural beauty of upstate New York. Smith, on the other hand, is located in a small city, providing easy access to urban amenities. While both locations have their advantages, your preference for a rural or urban lifestyle may play a significant role in your decision-making process.

It is important to consider the impact of location on your overall college experience. At Colgate, students have the opportunity to participate in outdoor activities such as hiking, skiing, and camping. The rural setting also provides a tight-knit community where students can form close relationships with their peers. At Smith, students have access to cultural events, museums, and restaurants in the nearby city. The urban setting also provides opportunities for internships and networking with professionals in various industries. Ultimately, your decision should be based on your personal preferences and goals for your college experience.

Academics: Majors, Programs, and Class Sizes

Both Colgate and Smith are highly respected for their academic programs. Colgate offers more than 50 majors and concentrations, and Smith offers more than 1,000 courses across 50 areas of study. One of the notable differences between the two is the class size; Colgate’s average class size is 18 students, while Smith’s is 15 students. Both universities offer personalized attention and a highly collaborative learning environment, with opportunities to engage in research, independent study, and internships.

Additionally, both Colgate and Smith have unique programs that set them apart. Colgate offers a highly regarded study group program, where students can travel with a faculty member and a small group of peers to study a particular topic in depth. Smith, on the other hand, has a strong focus on women’s education and leadership, with programs such as the Women’s Leadership Network and the Women’s Narratives Project. These programs provide students with opportunities to develop their leadership skills and explore issues related to gender and identity.

Faculty: Experience, Awards, and Research Work

Another important aspect to consider when comparing universities is the faculty. Both Colgate and Smith are home to accomplished and distinguished faculty members who offer a wealth of experience and knowledge to students. Many faculty members at both universities have won awards and grants for their research. Colgate also has a student-to-faculty ratio of 9:1, meaning students have excellent opportunities to build relationships with their professors. Smith has an impressive student-to-faculty ratio of 8:1.

A man talking to his teacher in a classroom.

In addition to their impressive credentials, both Colgate and Smith faculty members are actively engaged in research work. Colgate faculty members have conducted research in fields such as neuroscience, environmental studies, and international relations. Smith faculty members have also made significant contributions to their respective fields, with research projects ranging from gender studies to computer science. This commitment to research ensures that students at both universities are exposed to the latest developments and advancements in their fields of study.

Student Life: Clubs, Sports, and Extracurricular Activities

Colgate and Smith both offer a wide variety of extracurricular activities. Students at Colgate can participate in more than 200 clubs and organizations, ranging from capella groups to political organizations. Colgate also has a competitive Division I sports program. Smith offers more than 100 student clubs and organizations, including community service groups, cultural organizations, and student government. Smith also has a variety of sports teams and is a member of Division III athletics.

Additionally, both Colgate and Smith offer opportunities for students to create their own clubs and organizations based on their interests. This allows students to explore new hobbies and passions, and to connect with others who share similar interests. These student-led groups have included everything from a beekeeping club to a Harry Potter fan club. The possibilities are endless, and students are encouraged to take the initiative and create their own communities on campus.

Admissions: Application Requirements and Selectivity Rates

When it comes to admissions, both Colgate and Smith are selective universities. Colgate’s acceptance rate hovers around 12%, while Smith’s is slightly more selective, at around 23%. Both universities require a strong academic record, extracurricular involvement, and solid test scores to be considered for admission.

In addition to these requirements, Colgate also places a strong emphasis on demonstrated interest in the university. This can include attending information sessions, visiting campus, and engaging with admissions representatives. Smith, on the other hand, values a diverse range of experiences and perspectives in their applicants, and actively seeks out students who have overcome challenges or have unique backgrounds.

Financial Aid: Scholarships, Grants, and Loans Available

Both universities offer significant financial aid to their students. Colgate is committed to making its education accessible to all students and meets 100% of the demonstrated needs of domestic students. Smith also offers need-based financial aid and merit-based scholarships. Both schools offer work-study programs and loans as well.

holding glass jar with money for education

It is important to note that the application process for financial aid varies between the two universities. Colgate requires the CSS Profile and FAFSA to be submitted by the stated deadlines, while Smith only requires the FAFSA. Additionally, Colgate offers a limited number of scholarships for international students, while Smith does not offer any international student scholarships at this time.

Alumni Network: Colgate vs Smith

Smith University is known for its impressive alumnae network, which includes notable women from politics, business, and entertainment. Colgate also has a strong alumni network that extends across a variety of fields. Both universities offer comprehensive career services to help students prepare for life after graduation, including access to internships, job opportunities, and networking events.

At Smith University, the alumni network is not only a source of professional connections but also a community of support for current students. Alumnae often return to campus to speak at events, mentor students, and offer advice on navigating the workforce. Similarly, Colgate’s alumni network is known for its willingness to help fellow graduates, whether it be through job referrals or informational interviews.

In addition to career services, both universities offer resources for students interested in pursuing graduate studies. Smith University has a dedicated office for graduate school advising, which provides guidance on selecting programs, preparing applications, and securing funding. Colgate’s Career Services also offers support for graduate school applicants, including workshops on writing personal statements and connecting with alumni in specific fields.

Campus Diversity: Ethnicity, Race, Gender Identity & Inclusion Efforts

Both Colgate and Smith have made efforts to promote diversity and inclusivity on their campuses. Colgate has a diversity, equity, and inclusion initiative that focuses on fostering an inclusive community. The initiative includes a variety of educational programs and resources for students. Smith has a similar commitment, with a variety of programs and initiatives aimed at promoting equity and inclusion. Smith was the first women’s college in the United States to adopt a gender identity and gender expression policy.

Colgate’s diversity and inclusion efforts also extend beyond the campus community. The university has partnerships with local organizations and initiatives that promote diversity and inclusion in the surrounding community. These partnerships include collaborations with organizations that support underrepresented groups, such as the LGBTQ+ community and people of color.

Similarly, Smith College has a strong commitment to promoting diversity and inclusion in its curriculum. The college offers a variety of courses that explore issues related to race, ethnicity, gender, and sexuality. These courses are designed to provide students with a deeper understanding of the experiences of marginalized communities and to promote empathy and understanding among all members of the campus community.

Rankings and Reputation of Colgate vs Smith 

Both universities are highly respected and well-regarded by academic publications like U.S. News and World Report. Colgate consistently ranks among the top 21 liberal arts colleges in the country, and Smith is consistently ranked in the top 16 women’s colleges. Both institutions have also been praised for their commitment to undergraduate teaching, with Colgate ranking third in the nation for undergraduate teaching and Smith ranking second in the nation for undergraduate research.

Additionally, Colgate University has a strong emphasis on community service and engagement, with over 70% of students participating in community service projects. The university also has a robust study abroad program, with over 60% of students studying abroad at some point during their undergraduate career. Smith University, on the other hand, has a long history of promoting women’s rights and gender equality, with notable alumnae including Gloria Steinem and Sylvia Plath. The university also has a diverse student body, with students from over 48 states and 68 countries.

Class Comparisons: Similarities and Differences in Curriculum

While both universities offer a wide range of majors and programs, there are some notable differences between the curricula at Colgate and Smith. Colgate has a strong focus on the liberal arts, with a general education requirement that includes courses in literature, science, and the arts. Smith also has a strong focus on the liberal arts, but its curriculum is more flexible and allows students to design their own programs of study.

A woman looking at paintings in the Museum of Modern Art

Additionally, Colgate has a strong emphasis on interdisciplinary studies, with many courses and programs that combine multiple fields of study. Smith, on the other hand, has a strong emphasis on women’s studies and gender studies, with a variety of courses and programs that explore these topics in depth. Both universities offer unique opportunities for students to explore their interests and passions, but their curricula have distinct focuses that may appeal to different types of learners.

Student Satisfaction Ratings: Colgate vs Smith

Both Colgate and Smith have high rates of student satisfaction. According to the National Survey of Student Engagement, Colgate students are more likely to report that their education has helped them think critically and solve real-world problems. Smith students are more likely to report that they feel challenged and engaged in their coursework.

Additionally, the survey found that both Colgate and Smith have high rates of student involvement in extracurricular activities. Colgate students are more likely to participate in community service and volunteer work, while Smith students are more likely to be involved in student organizations and clubs. This shows that both schools offer a well-rounded college experience that goes beyond just academics.

Post-Graduate Opportunities in Colgate University vs Smith University

Both Colgate and Smith offer excellent post-graduate opportunities for their students. According to the Wall Street Journal, Colgate has one of the highest graduate school acceptance rates in the country, with around 12% of graduates going on to pursue graduate degrees. Smith also has a strong record of post-graduate success, with a 23% acceptance rate into medical schools and a 100% acceptance rate into law schools.

However, the post-graduate opportunities at Colgate and Smith differ in terms of their focus. Colgate has a strong emphasis on research and offers a wide range of research opportunities for its post-graduate students. On the other hand, Smith has a more practical approach and provides its post-graduate students with hands-on experience through internships and externships.

Another factor to consider when comparing post-graduate opportunities at Colgate and Smith is the availability of funding. Colgate offers a variety of funding options for its post-graduate students, including research grants and fellowships. Smith, on the other hand, has a strong network of alumni who provide financial support to its post-graduate students.

Cost of Attendance Comparison: Colgate vs Smith

When it comes to cost, both universities are comparable. Colgate’s cost of attendance for the academic year is around $83,814, which includes tuition, fees, and room and board. Smith’s cost of attendance for the same academic year is around $82,878, which includes tuition, fees, and room and board.

However, it is important to note that both universities offer financial aid and scholarships to eligible students. Colgate offers need-based financial aid and merit-based scholarships, while Smith offers need-based financial aid, merit-based scholarships, and talent-based awards for students with exceptional abilities in areas such as music, art, and athletics.

a student playing violin

In addition to financial aid, both universities also offer work-study programs to help students offset the cost of attendance. Colgate’s work-study program provides students with part-time jobs on campus, while Smith’s program offers both on-campus and off-campus job opportunities.

Conclusion: Which is the Best University for You?

Ultimately, the decision between Colgate and Smith will depend on your individual needs and preferences. If you are looking for a rural campus with a focus on the liberal arts, Colgate may be the right choice for you. If you prefer a more urban location with a strong commitment to women’s education, Smith may be the better option. Both universities offer excellent academic programs, impressive alumni networks, and a wide range of extracurricular activities. Whichever university you choose, you can be sure that you will receive an exceptional education that will prepare you for success in whatever path you choose.

It is important to consider factors beyond academics when making your decision. Colgate offers a strong sense of community and a tight-knit student body, while Smith has a reputation for fostering a supportive and empowering environment for women. Additionally, Colgate has a Division I athletics program, while Smith has a focus on club sports and fitness classes.

Ultimately, visiting both campuses and speaking with current students and faculty members can help you make an informed decision. Consider what is most important to you in a university experience and choose the school that aligns with your values and goals.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sign up now to receive insights on
how to navigate the college admissions process.