Dartmouth vs. Carnegie Mellon: A Comprehensive Analysis

July 15, 2023
By AdmissionSight

Dartmouth vs. Carnegie Mellon: A Comprehensive Analysis

In this article, we’ll dive into the detailed comparison of two prestigious universities in the United States – Dartmouth vs. Carnegie Mellon. Both institutions have a diverse range of academic programs and renowned faculty members.

We’ll look at various factors such as campus culture, admissions processes, campus facilities, alumni networks, athletics, student success rates, location, and other crucial aspects to help you make an informed decision when choosing a university to attend.

Introduction to the Two Universities

Let’s start by understanding the roots of the two universities. Founded in 1769, Dartmouth College is located in Hanover, New Hampshire, and is known for its strong undergraduate liberal arts focus with graduate programs in business, engineering, and sciences.

Carnegie Mellon University, founded in 1900, is in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, and is a renowned research university with a particular emphasis on computer science, engineering, arts, and business.

Despite their differences, both universities share a commitment to academic excellence and innovation. Dartmouth College has a long-standing tradition of providing a personalized education experience with small class sizes and a close-knit community.

Carnegie Mellon University, on the other hand, is known for its interdisciplinary approach to research and education, encouraging collaboration across different fields of study. Both universities have produced numerous successful alumni who have made significant contributions to their respective fields.

Dartmouth vs. Carnegie Mellon: Academic Programs Offered

Both Dartmouth and Carnegie Mellon offer a diverse range of academic programs that cover numerous fields of study. Dartmouth’s undergraduate program emphasizes liberal arts, while Carnegie Mellon’s undergraduate program provides a combination of liberal arts and technical training.

Graduate programs at both institutions are highly regarded. Dartmouth has graduate programs in business, engineering, and sciences, and Carnegie Mellon has various graduate programs in computer science, engineering, arts, and business.

View of a female student working in front of her computer.

Dartmouth College is known for its strong commitment to undergraduate research. The college offers numerous research opportunities to its students, including the opportunity to work with faculty members on research projects.

Carnegie Mellon, on the other hand, is known for its cutting-edge research in computer science and engineering. The university has a number of research centers and institutes that focus on areas such as robotics, artificial intelligence, and cybersecurity.

In addition to their academic programs, both Dartmouth and Carnegie Mellon offer a wide range of extracurricular activities. Dartmouth has over 200 student organizations, including clubs for sports, music, theater, and community service.

Carnegie Mellon has a vibrant arts scene, with numerous student-run theater productions, music ensembles, and art exhibitions. The university also has a strong athletics program, with 17 varsity sports teams that compete in the NCAA Division III.

Dartmouth vs. Carnegie Mellon: Faculty and Research Opportunities

Dartmouth and Carnegie Mellon have world-class faculty members with many renowned researchers and professors. At Dartmouth, students are encouraged to conduct research as part of their undergraduate curriculum, while Carnegie Mellon has a strong focus on graduate-level research. Both universities offer ample opportunities for students to participate in research opportunities, internships, and co-curricular activities.

Additionally, Dartmouth and Carnegie Mellon have state-of-the-art research facilities and equipment, providing students with access to cutting-edge technology and resources. At Dartmouth, the Thayer School of Engineering has a variety of research centers, including the Center for Digital Health, the Center for Energy, and the Center for Surgical Innovation.

Carnegie Mellon’s Robotics Institute is one of the top robotics research centers in the world, with a focus on developing robots for a variety of applications, including healthcare, manufacturing, and space exploration.

Dartmouth vs. Carnegie Mellon: Campus Culture and Student Life

At Dartmouth, students are encouraged to develop leadership and teamwork through their residential life system. It is comprised of six residential communities where students live and learn together. Carnegie Mellon offers a diverse campus culture that is centered around student organizations and clubs.

Students can participate in various extracurricular activities such as athletics, arts, music, dance, and community outreach at both universities.

However, there are some differences in the student life experience at Dartmouth and Carnegie Mellon. Dartmouth has a strong focus on outdoor activities and offers a variety of outdoor programs, such as hiking, skiing, and camping.

On the other hand, Carnegie Mellon has a thriving arts scene and is home to the College of Fine Arts, which offers programs in drama, music, art, and design. Additionally, Carnegie Mellon has a strong emphasis on entrepreneurship and innovation, with many resources available for students to start their own businesses or pursue research projects.

Admissions Process and Acceptance Rates at Dartmouth vs. Carnegie Mellon

The admissions processes at both universities are highly competitive. Dartmouth’s acceptance rate for the class of 2023 was 7.9%, while Carnegie Mellon’s acceptance rate for the class of 2024 was 15%. It is essential to have a strong academic track record, outstanding test scores, and recommendations to get accepted into either university.

Portrait of smiling asian male student sitting at desk in classroom at university,

However, there are some differences in the admissions process between the two universities. Dartmouth places a strong emphasis on extracurricular activities and community involvement, while Carnegie Mellon focuses more on academic achievements and research experience.

Additionally, Dartmouth offers an Early Decision option, which can increase your chances of acceptance if you are committed to attending the university.

Once accepted, both universities offer a rigorous academic experience and a range of opportunities for students to get involved in research, internships, and extracurricular activities. Dartmouth is known for its strong liberal arts curriculum and small class sizes, while Carnegie Mellon is renowned for its programs in computer science, engineering, and the arts.

Dartmouth vs. Carnegie Mellon: Campus Facilities

Both universities have top-tier facilities, including state-of-the-art dorms, dining halls, and libraries. Dartmouth has a traditional New England campus with iconic architecture, while Carnegie Mellon has modern buildings and facilities.

Additionally, Dartmouth’s campus boasts a natural beauty with its location in the scenic Upper Valley region of New Hampshire. The campus is surrounded by lush forests and offers numerous outdoor recreational opportunities.

On the other hand, Carnegie Mellon’s urban campus is located in the heart of Pittsburgh, providing students with easy access to the city’s cultural attractions and professional opportunities.

Dartmouth vs. Carnegie Mellon: Alumni Network and Career Opportunities

Both universities have a robust alumni network that provides many opportunities to connect with professionals worldwide. Dartmouth has a strong emphasis on preparing students for liberal arts careers, while Carnegie Mellon has a focus on career readiness in technology, business, and arts.

Additionally, Dartmouth’s alumni network has a strong presence in the fields of education, government, and non-profit organizations. This provides students with opportunities to explore careers in these areas and connect with alumni who have made successful careers in these fields.

On the other hand, Carnegie Mellon’s alumni network has a strong presence in the tech industry, with many graduates going on to work for major tech companies such as Google, Apple, and Microsoft.

The university also has a strong entrepreneurship program, which provides students with the skills and resources to start their own businesses and connect with successful alumni entrepreneurs.

Cost of Attendance and Financial Aid Options at Dartmouth and Carnegie Mellon

The cost of attendance for both universities is high, with tuition costs, room and board, and other fees adding up to tens of thousands of dollars per year. Both universities offer financial aid to students based on merit and need, with Dartmouth’s average financial aid package covering around 68% of tuition and fees.

Carnegie Mellon’s average financial aid award covers around 64% of tuition and fees.

It is important to note that the cost of attendance can vary depending on a student’s individual circumstances, such as their major, housing choices, and personal expenses. Additionally, both universities offer work-study programs and student employment opportunities to help offset the cost of attendance.

Furthermore, Dartmouth and Carnegie Mellon have different policies regarding the use of outside scholarships to supplement financial aid packages. While Dartmouth allows students to use outside scholarships to reduce their expected family contribution, Carnegie Mellon reduces their institutional aid by the amount of any outside scholarships received.

Athletics and Sports Programs Offered By Both Universities

View of sports equipments placed on the floor.

Dartmouth has a strong athletic program with competitive teams in football, basketball, soccer, and hockey, among others. They are members of the NCAA Division I and the Ivy League. Carnegie Mellon has an equally competitive sports program with 17 intercollegiate varsity teams and is a member of the NCAA Division III.

In addition to the varsity teams, both universities offer a variety of club and intramural sports for students to participate in. Dartmouth has over 30 club sports teams, including ultimate frisbee, rugby, and sailing. Carnegie Mellon has over 20 club sports teams, including fencing, quidditch, and equestrian.

Both universities also prioritize the health and wellness of their students, offering state-of-the-art fitness facilities and resources. Dartmouth’s Zimmerman Fitness Center includes a pool, weight room, and cardio equipment, as well as group fitness classes and personal training.

Carnegie Mellon’s Cohon University Center houses a fitness center, indoor track, and basketball courts, as well as wellness programs and nutrition counseling.

Dartmouth vs. Carnegie Mellon: Student Success Rates

Dartmouth and Carnegie Mellon have high student success rates, with Dartmouth’s graduation rate hovering around 95%, and Carnegie Mellon’s graduation rate is around 88%. Both universities have a strong focus on career preparedness, with high job placement rates for recent graduates.

In addition to high graduation rates and job placement rates, both Dartmouth and Carnegie Mellon have a variety of resources available to support student success. Dartmouth offers a comprehensive advising program, with advisors available to help students navigate academic and personal challenges.

Carnegie Mellon has a robust career services department, which provides students with access to job fairs, networking events, and internship opportunities.

Furthermore, both universities prioritize diversity and inclusion in their student populations. Dartmouth has a number of initiatives aimed at increasing diversity, including a program that provides financial support to low-income and first-generation college students.

Carnegie Mellon has a strong commitment to gender equity, with a number of programs and resources available to support women in STEM fields.

Notable Alumni from Dartmouth and Carnegie Mellon

Dartmouth’s notable alumni include poet Robert Frost, investor, and entrepreneur Peter Thiel, and former US Secretary of the Treasury Timothy Geithner. Carnegie Mellon’s notable alumni include former CEO of Google, Eric Schmidt; playwright August Wilson; and Nobel laureate and physicist John C. Mather.

In addition to these notable alumni, Dartmouth has also produced several prominent politicians, including former US Senator and Secretary of State Daniel Webster, former Governor of New Hampshire John Lynch, and former US Senator Judd Gregg.

Carnegie Mellon has also had a significant impact on the entertainment industry, with notable alumni such as actor Ted Danson, composer and lyricist Stephen Schwartz, and filmmaker George Romero.

Dartmouth vs. Carnegie Mellon: Differences in Location and Surrounding Area

Dartmouth is located in Hanover, New Hampshire, in a rural area surrounded by mountains and natural beauty. Carnegie Mellon is located in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, a bustling urban city known for its innovation and technology.

Due to its rural location, Dartmouth offers students a unique opportunity to connect with nature and participate in outdoor activities such as hiking, skiing, and camping. The surrounding area is also home to several small towns with a strong sense of community.

In contrast, Carnegie Mellon’s location in Pittsburgh provides students with access to a vibrant city culture, including museums, theaters, and a diverse food scene. The city is also a hub for technology and innovation, with many opportunities for students to engage in research and internships in these fields.

Academic Rankings of Dartmouth vs. Carnegie Mellon

Both universities have consistently ranked highly in various academic rankings. According to the US News & World Report, Dartmouth is ranked #12 in the National Liberal Arts College ranking, and Carnegie Mellon is ranked #26 in the National University ranking.

A teacher talking to her middle school students.

However, in the QS World University Rankings, Carnegie Mellon is ranked #48, while Dartmouth is ranked #207. This is due to Carnegie Mellon’s strong reputation in computer science and engineering, while Dartmouth’s strengths lie in the liberal arts and undergraduate teaching.

Conclusion: Which University is the Better Choice for You?

Choosing between Dartmouth and Carnegie Mellon ultimately depends on a variety of personal factors, including academic interests, location preference, campus culture, and career goals.

We’ve provided a detailed comparison of the universities, and we hope that it helps you make an informed decision when considering these two exceptional institutions. Both universities offer top-tier academics, world-renowned faculty, and a range of opportunities to develop professionally and personally.

However, it’s important to note that Dartmouth has a strong focus on undergraduate education, with small class sizes and a close-knit community.

On the other hand, Carnegie Mellon is known for its cutting-edge research and innovation, particularly in the fields of computer science and engineering. Consider your priorities and what you value most in a university experience when making your decision.


Are you feeling overwhelmed by the college admission process? Look no further! AdmissionSight is here to guide you toward success. With our specialized college admission consultation service, we offer personalized assistance tailored to your unique goals and aspirations.

Our experienced consultants will provide expert advice on crafting a standout application, selecting the right colleges, and navigating the complex admissions world. Don’t let stress hold you back—let AdmissionSight be your trusted partner on your journey to higher education. Contact us today to take the first step toward a brighter future.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sign up now to receive insights on
how to navigate the college admissions process.