Carleton vs. Williams: Which College is the Better Choice?

By Eric Eng

By Eric Eng

A female student sitting on a coach while holding a notebook and a pen.

Carleton vs. Williams: Which College is the Better Choice?

Are you trying to decide between Carleton College and Williams College? These two liberal arts colleges have much in common, but there are also differences to take into consideration before making your final decision.

In this article, we will explore various aspects of Carleton vs. Williams, highlighting what makes each unique. By the end of this article, you will be able to make an informed decision about which college is the better choice for you.

Introduction to Carleton and Williams Colleges

Carleton College and Williams College are both highly-regarded liberal arts colleges located in the United States. Carleton is located in Northfield, Minnesota, while Williams is located in Williamstown, Massachusetts. Both colleges are known for their rigorous academic programs, stunning campuses, and close-knit communities.

Carleton College has a student population of around 2,000, while Williams College has a slightly larger student population of around 2,100. Both colleges have a low student-to-faculty ratio, which allows for personalized attention and mentorship from professors.

Carleton is particularly known for its strong programs in the sciences and mathematics, while Williams is known for its strong programs in the arts and humanities. Despite their differences, both colleges offer a well-rounded education and a supportive community for students to thrive in.

Carleton vs. Williams: Campus Environment and Location

Carleton’s campus is located in a small town, with a population of just over 20,000. The campus is surrounded by prairies, forests, and rivers, providing a peaceful and serene environment for students to focus on their studies.

In contrast, Williams is located in a more densely populated area, with a population of about 8,000. The area surrounding Williams is known for its natural beauty, with the Berkshire Mountains providing scenic views for students.

Additionally, Carleton’s campus is known for its sustainability efforts, with many buildings being LEED certified and the campus implementing various eco-friendly initiatives. The town of Northfield, where Carleton is located, also has a strong commitment to sustainability, with many local businesses and organizations promoting environmentally conscious practices. This creates a unique and environmentally conscious atmosphere for students at Carleton.

Carleton vs. Williams: Academic Programs and Opportunities

Both Carleton and Williams are known for their strong academic programs. Carleton offers over 30 majors and 17 interdisciplinary concentrations, while Williams offers 36 majors and interdisciplinary programs.

Both colleges emphasize a broad-based education, encouraging students to pursue a variety of interests while still receiving a well-rounded education. Both schools have various study abroad opportunities, research programs, and internships available for students to take advantage of.

Additionally, Carleton and Williams both have strong graduate programs, with Carleton offering graduate degrees in fields such as education, public policy, and computer science, and Williams offering graduate programs in art history, economics, and mathematics. These graduate programs provide students with the opportunity to continue their education and specialize in their chosen field.

Furthermore, both colleges have extensive libraries and research facilities, with Carleton’s Gould Library housing over 400,000 volumes and Williams’ Sawyer Library housing over 1.5 million volumes. These libraries provide students with access to a wide range of resources and materials, allowing them to conduct in-depth research and further their academic pursuits.

Carleton vs. Williams: Admission Requirements and Selectivity

Carleton and Williams are both highly selective colleges, with acceptance rates below 20%. Both colleges require rigorous academic standards and extracurricular involvement from their applicants. While Williams has a slightly higher SAT score range for admitted students, the overall academic rigor of both schools is relatively similar.

Additionally, Carleton and Williams both value diversity and seek to create a diverse student body. They consider factors such as race, ethnicity, socioeconomic status, and geographic location in their admissions process. Both colleges also offer need-blind admissions, meaning that a student’s financial need is not taken into account when making admissions decisions.

Furthermore, Carleton and Williams have holistic admissions processes, meaning that they consider the whole applicant, not just their academic and extracurricular achievements. They also value demonstrated interest, such as visiting the campus or attending information sessions, as it shows a genuine interest in the school.

Both colleges also offer interviews with alumni or admissions officers as part of the application process.

woman in white shirt typing her laptop

Carleton vs. Williams: Student Life and Extracurricular Activities

Both Carleton and Williams offer a wide variety of extracurricular activities for their students. Carleton has over 200 student-run organizations, including club sports, music groups, and political clubs. Williams, similarly, has over 150 student organizations, ranging from club sports to literary magazines. Both colleges have a strong sense of community, with students bonding over shared interests and experiences.

Additionally, both Carleton and Williams have robust student life programs that offer a range of events and activities throughout the year. From concerts and movie screenings to guest speakers and cultural festivals, there is always something happening on campus. These events provide students with opportunities to learn, grow, and connect with their peers outside of the classroom.

Carleton vs. Williams: Housing and Dining Options

Both Carleton and Williams offer on-campus housing options for their students. Carleton has a wide range of housing options, including traditional dormitory-style rooms and apartment-style living.

Similarly, Williams has a variety of housing options, including traditional dorms, suite-style living, and special interest houses. Both colleges offer on-campus dining options, with Carleton having eight dining options and Williams having five.

Additionally, both colleges offer off-campus housing options for upperclassmen who prefer to live off-campus. Carleton has a variety of off-campus housing options, including apartments and houses located within walking distance of campus. Williams also offers off-campus housing options, with many students choosing to live in nearby apartments or houses in the surrounding community.

Carleton vs. Williams: Career Resources and Outcomes

Both Carleton and Williams have strong career resources available for their students. Carleton has a robust Career Center, which offers career counseling, internships, and networking opportunities for students.

Similarly, Williams has a Career Center that provides similar services, as well as an extensive alumni network that can assist students in their post-college endeavors. Graduates from both colleges have gone on to success in a variety of fields, with both schools boasting high rates of job placement and graduate school acceptance.

Additionally, both Carleton and Williams have strong partnerships with local and national companies, providing students with opportunities for hands-on experience and potential job offers upon graduation.

Carleton has partnerships with companies such as 3M, Target, and Medtronic, while Williams has partnerships with companies such as Goldman Sachs, Google, and Teach for America. These partnerships not only provide valuable experience for students, but also demonstrate the high regard in which these companies hold graduates from these institutions.

A woman typing in a library.

Carleton vs. Williams: Athletics and Sports Culture

Both Carleton and Williams have a collegiate sports program, with athletics being an integral part of campus life. Carleton is a member of the Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference and offers 20 varsity sports, while Williams is a member of the New England Small College Athletic Conference and offers 32 varsity sports. Both schools have a strong sports culture, with many students participating in varsity or recreational sports.

At Carleton, the athletic facilities are top-notch, with a recently renovated gymnasium, a fieldhouse, and a brand new football stadium. The school also has a strong tradition of intramural sports, with students forming teams and competing against each other in a variety of sports.

Williams, on the other hand, has a long history of success in varsity sports, with numerous national championships in sports such as cross country, skiing, and tennis. The school also has a strong emphasis on fitness and wellness, with a state-of-the-art fitness center and a variety of fitness classes offered to students.

Carleton vs. Williams: Cost of Attendance and Financial Aid Opportunities

Both Carleton and Williams are expensive colleges, with tuition, room, and board costing upwards of $70,000 per year. However, both colleges offer extensive financial aid packages, including need-based aid and merit-based scholarships. Both schools are committed to making their education accessible to students from all backgrounds, and work with families to ensure they can afford to attend.

Carleton College offers a unique program called the Carleton College Summer Program, which allows students to earn college credits during the summer before their first year. This program can help students reduce the overall cost of attendance by allowing them to graduate early or take fewer classes during the academic year.

Additionally, Williams College offers a program called the Williams College Investment Office, which manages the college’s endowment and invests in a variety of assets. The returns from these investments are used to support financial aid programs and other initiatives that benefit students.

Both Carleton and Williams also offer work-study programs, which allow students to earn money while gaining valuable work experience. These programs provide students with part-time jobs on campus, and the earnings can be used to offset the cost of attendance.

Additionally, both colleges have partnerships with local businesses and organizations, which provide students with additional job opportunities and internships. These partnerships can help students gain valuable experience in their field of study and build their professional network.

Carleton vs. Williams: Alumni Network and Reputation

Both Carleton and Williams have strong reputations in the academic world. Carleton is consistently ranked as one of the top liberal arts colleges in the country, while Williams is similarly highly-regarded. Both colleges have extensive alumni networks, with graduates going on to success in a variety of fields.

Alumni from both colleges often stay connected with their alma maters, providing support for current students and participating in school events.

Carleton’s alumni network is particularly strong in the fields of science and technology, with many graduates going on to work for major tech companies such as Google and Microsoft. Williams, on the other hand, has a strong presence in the arts and humanities, with many alumni pursuing careers in fields such as literature, theater, and music.

Both colleges also have a reputation for producing graduates who are highly engaged in their communities and committed to making a positive impact in the world. Many alumni from both Carleton and Williams go on to work in public service, non-profit organizations, and other fields where they can make a difference in the lives of others.

Student Perspectives on Carleton vs. Williams

At the end of the day, the best way to determine whether Carleton or Williams is the better choice for you is to speak with current or former students of both colleges. Student perspectives can provide insight into what it’s like to attend each school, and can help you determine which school aligns best with your personality and goals.

Some factors to consider when speaking with students include the academic rigor of each school, the social scene, extracurricular opportunities, and the overall campus culture. It’s important to ask specific questions and get a sense of what day-to-day life is like at each school.

Additionally, you may want to consider reaching out to alumni who have gone on to pursue careers in your field of interest, as they can provide valuable insight into how their college experience prepared them for their career.

Group of students smiling and talking to each other.

Conclusion: Making the Decision that’s Right for You

When deciding between Carleton and Williams, it’s important to consider all aspects of each college, including campus environment, academic programs, extracurricular activities, and financial aid opportunities.

Both colleges offer a high-quality education and strong sense of community, making the decision between the two a difficult one. Ultimately, choosing between Carleton and Williams comes down to personal preference, with each college offering a unique and rewarding experience.

It’s also important to consider the location of each college and how it may impact your overall college experience. Carleton is located in a small town in Minnesota, while Williams is located in a rural area in Massachusetts.

This may affect the types of activities and opportunities available outside of campus. Additionally, the weather and climate of each location should also be taken into consideration. Ultimately, it’s important to weigh all factors and make the decision that feels right for you and your individual needs.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sign up now to receive insights on
how to navigate the college admissions process.